Pyke made an impressive debut in the
NAB Cup match against
Port Adelaide. His performance rucking against premiership ruckmen
Dean Brogan and
Brendon Lade earned him early favouritism to take the secondary ruckman role, supporting premiership ruckman
Darren Jolly and make his AFL premiership season debut in the Swans' opening match against St Kilda. Despite a solid performance in his debut, Pyke's conversion was criticized by some AFL commentators, most notably
Brian Taylor, who described the experiment in 2009 as a "joke" and described him as the worst player in the AFL. He was elevated to the senior list shortly before the first round, leading to speculation he would indeed be chosen, but he was announced on the emergency list for the squad, with
Jesse White taking the second ruck spot. In the following rounds, Pyke played for the Swans' reserves side in the
AFL Canberra league. After a 20 possession strong performance with the reserves including some strong contested marks and goals, the club raised the possibility that Pyke's debut would take place in the coming weeks. Pyke finally got his opportunity with the Swans when selected to play in round 6 of the AFL premiership competition against the
Richmond Tigers. In 50 minutes of game time, he accumulated 4 handballs, 1 mark, 1 tackle and 11 hit-outs. While his debut wasn't sensational, he showed enough confident passages of play to be considered as a back-up ruckman for the Swans. By Round 14, 2010, Pyke finally managed his first senior goal, again against Richmond. In August 2010 Pyke was given a new two-year contract with the Sydney Swans. Swans' coach
Paul Roos praised Pyke, saying he had developed into a genuine AFL ruckman. "This year, if someone came to their first game, you'd have to point out that this is a Canadian rugby player now playing AFL football, and that's the biggest compliment you can give Pykey," Roos said. The success of Pyke's move to the AFL was further cemented at the 2010 Sydney Swans Club Champion presentation, where Pyke was awarded the
Dennis Carroll Trophy for Most Improved Player. In the 2011 season, Pyke played only two games before an ongoing quad muscle injury kept him off the senior side for the rest of the season. After missing selection for round one of the 2012 season, Pyke injured his posterior cruciate ligament playing in the reserves. He made his return in Round 8, 2012, to a Sydney Swans starting side destined to win the Grand Final. The Swans added his blog, "Open Pyke", to their website in June 2012 and his goal against the West Coast Eagles was featured as the SwansTV Play of the Day for Round 16. In Round 21 Pyke scored a career-high three goals against the Western Bulldogs. With the Sydney Swans' win in the 2012 Grand Final on 29 September 2012, Pyke became the first Canadian to play in an AFL premiership winning team. When Swans coach
John Longmire substituted primary ruckman
Shane Mumford, suffering from a sore hamstring, out of the game in the fourth term, Pyke was left to handle the ruck duties alone. He was recognised as playing an important role in the Swans' win. He was credited with 16 disposals, a career high, and three contested marks, more than anyone else on the field except Hawthorn star
Lance Franklin, who took four. The Swans signed Pyke to another two-year contract in 2012, and he played in all 25 games for the Swans' 2013 season. He took 52 contested marks, more than any player in the competition except
Travis Cloke, Pyke's success on the field led former Sydney coach Paul Roos to hold him out as a contender for the
2013 All-Australian team. It was to be his best season. Pre-season surgery and a hamstring injury hampered Pyke during the 2014 season. He played in 19 games, including the Swans' three finals matches. He had a career-best 53 hitouts in Round 17 against Carlton, but his best outing was arguably in Round 19 against Essendon when he had 49 hitouts, three contested marks, six tackles and a goal. On 23 September 2014, it was announced that Pyke had signed another contract to remain with the Swans until the end of 2016. After a good first half of the 2015 season, in which he averaged 33 hitouts a game, knee problems caused Pyke's form to drop off. He missed four games and averaged fewer than 18 hitouts per game over the last half of the season and the finals. His season overall was characterised as "below par but serviceable" by the Swans. On 15 September 2015 Pyke, who had recently earned a master's degree in Commerce (Finance) from the University of Sydney, was awarded the AFL Players Association's Education and Training Excellence Award "for his outstanding commitment to his Masters in Commerce and career development." On 16 October 2015, Pyke announced his retirement from the AFL in typically understated fashion by posting a photo on Twitter of his boots hanging up inside his locker at the SCG. "I got to the point where I didn't think I had any more improvement left in me and that's when you know to step aside and let the younger players come through," he said of his decision. ==Statistics==