Box office The film was a box-office success. According to Warner Bros., it earned $3,483,000 () in the United States and $2,155,000 () in other markets. Writing in
The Nation in 1945, film critic and author
James Agee: "Nasty, gratifying version of the James Cain novel... Attempt made to sell Mildred as noble when she is merely idiotic or at best pathetic; but constant, virulent, lambent attention to money and its effects, and more authentic suggestions of sex than one hopes to see in American films."
Pauline Kael wrote: "Miss Crawford's heavy breathing was certified as acting when she won an Academy Award for her performance here."
Leslie Halliwell gave it two of four stars: "A woman's picture par excellence, glossily and moodily photographed, with a star suffering in luxury on behalf of the most ungrateful daughter of all time." Film critic of the time,
Pauline Kael, mentions that the film, and others like it, work on the seducing adult being sophisticated and worldly while the manipulated youth are basically innocent kids. William Brogdon of
Variety liked the film, especially the screenplay, and wrote:At first reading James M. Cain's novel of the same title might not suggest screenable material, but the cleanup job has resulted in a class feature, showmanly produced by Jerry Wald and tellingly directed by Michael Curtiz ... The dramatics are heavy but so skillfully handled that they never cloy. Joan Crawford reaches a peak of her acting career in this pic. Ann Blyth, as the daughter, scores dramatically in her first genuine acting assignment. Zachary Scott makes the most of his character as the Pasadena heel, a talented performance. ''
Harrison's Reports'' wrote that Crawford delivered a "good performance", but the story "lacks conviction, and the main characterizations are overdrawn. For example, the daughter's hatred for her mother has no logical basis, consequently, it weakens the story."
John McCarten of
The New Yorker wrote:Certainly, despite its unconscionable length—it takes almost two hours—
Mildred Pierce contains enough excitement to jolt even the most lethargic customer...it is pleasant to report that Miss Crawford is no longer as frantic in appearance as she once was. Despite all kinds of chances to go berserk as a Cain mother, Miss Crawford remains subdued and reasonable, like most of the rest of a highly competent cast. In a 2005 review, Jeremiah Kipp of
Slant Magazine gave the film a mixed review:
Mildred Pierce is melodramatic trash, constructed like a reliable
Aristotelian warhorse where characters have planted the seeds of their own doom in the first act, only to have grief-stricken revelations at the climax. Directed by studio favorite Michael Curtiz in
German Expressionistic mode, which doesn't quite go with the California beaches and sunlight but sets the bleak tone of domestic film noir, and scored by
Max Steiner with a sensational bombast that's rousing even when it doesn't match the quieter, pensive mood of individual scenes,
Mildred Pierce is professionally executed and moves at a brisk clip. In 1978, historian June Sochen argued the film lies at the intersection of the "weepie" and "independent woman" genres of the 1930s and 1940s. It accentuates common ground of the two: Women must be submissive, live through others, and remain in the home. In his 1986 book
Guide for the Film Fanatic,
Danny Peary wrote, Peary also wrote, The February 2020 issue of
New York Magazine lists
Mildred Pierce as among "The Best Movies That Lost Best Picture at the Oscars." On the
review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds an approval rating of 88% based on 50 reviews, with an average rating of 8.1/10. The website's critics consensus reads, "Tied together by a powerhouse performance from Joan Crawford,
Mildred Pierce blends noir and social drama to soapily intoxicating effect.".
Gay Following Mildred Pierce is the focus of David M. Halperin's 2012 book
How to be Gay, which describes the film as "a gay male cult classic," which "helped Crawford achieve her status as a notorious gay icon."
Accolades American Film Institute lists •
AFI's 100 Years ... 100 Heroes and Villains: • Veda Pierce – Nominated Villain •
AFI's 100 Years ... 100 Movie Quotes: • "Personally, Veda's convinced me that alligators have the right idea. They eat their young." – Nominated •
AFI's 100 Years ... 100 Movies (10th Anniversary Edition) – Nominated ==Adaptations==