During the 1980s and 1990s, as the number of
Conservative MPs for Welsh constituencies dwindled almost to zero, the office fell into disrepute.
Nicholas Edwards, MP for
Pembrokeshire, held the post for eight years. On his departure, the government ceased to look within Wales for the secretary of state, and the post was increasingly used as a way of getting junior high-fliers into the
Cabinet.
John Redwood in particular caused embarrassment when he publicly demonstrated his inability to sing "
Hen Wlad Fy Nhadau", the Welsh
national anthem, at a conference. The introduction of the
National Assembly for Wales and the
Welsh Government, after the
devolution referendum of 1997, was the beginning of a new era. On 1 July 1999 the majority of the functions of the Welsh Office transferred to the new assembly. The Welsh Office was disbanded, but the post of Secretary of State for Wales was retained, as the head of the newly created Wales Office. Since 1999 there have been calls for the office of Welsh secretary to be scrapped or merged with the posts of
Secretary of State for Scotland and
Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, to reflect the lesser powers of the role since devolution. Those calling for a Secretary of State for the Union include Robert Hazell, in a department into which
Rodney Brazier has suggested adding a Minister of State for England with responsibility for
English local government. In June 2024,
Plaid Cymru, the Welsh nationalist party, called for the position's abolishment describing it as "outdated", that it "entrench[es]" a power imbalance, and its powers should be devolved. The party's representatives accused the
shadow Labour holder,
Jo Stevens, of having a "contemptuous attitude towards devolution" based on Stevens' comments relating to
High Speed 2 and
justice and policing. The Conservative incumbent
David TC Davies expressed his surprise, stating that the "so-called 'party of Wales' is now wanting to silence Wales' voice [in the cabinet]". In Plaid Cymru's motion on 26 June, calling for the post's abolishment, leader of the
Welsh Conservatives,
Andrew RT Davies, supported the motion after being confused it was a Tory amendment being voted on. ==Ministers and secretaries of state==