Bob Grimm of
Tucson Weekly said that
Miracle on Ice falls short of being even a good sports movie, stating it made too many errors on and off the ice, failing to capture the essence of the sport it's studying, and reducing most of the men and women involved in the historical drama to caricature. Outside of archive footage,
defenseman Mike Ramsey wasn't depicted in
Miracle on Ice. In the February 21, 1998 edition of
The Buffalo News, Ramsey said "I also got paid for having my name in the TV movie that ABC did. It was about five years before I sat down and actually watched the movie. I sat back and said 'Uh, oh' when it was over because it wasn't too good. Some time after that, we (the
Sabres) came into some city on a road trip at 2 a.m., and it was on TV. I think everyone on the team watched it, because the next morning everyone was busting my chops." Patti Brooks, who is depicted in
Miracle on Ice by
Jessica Walter said in 2009 “I don’t know that I ever watched the whole movie.” In regards to Karl Malden's portrayal of her husband, she said “I remember Herbie would not watch it. People used to tease him about Karl Malden playing him. Would you? That would be like
Ma Kettle playing me. But you always think that you’re sharper than others think you are. But to be honest, I don’t know why they chose him. I don’t think (Malden) ever went on the ice in his movie; he was too old.” Patti Brooks' brother, Terry Lane added "It was so bad", and was unable to fathom how Karl Malden, at age 69, could be cast in the role of the handsome Herb Brooks, who was 42 when the actual "
Miracle on Ice" took place. Herb Brooks himself stated that his wife would've preferred
Robert Redford to have played him. Meanwhile, Mike Eruzione claimed to the
Star Tribune that Brooks wanted
Paul Newman to play him.
Miracle director
Gavin O'Connor said that he remembers calling Herb Brooks to tell him that Karl Malden had been cast to play him and hearing a second or two of silence on the line before he replied, in a tone dripping with acid, ‘Isn’t he a bit old?’ On the other hand, Tom Jones of the
Tampa Bay Times said that while the movie was a bit hokey and included some strange choices (such as Steve Guttenberg as goalie Jim Craig), Karl Malden pulled off a credible performance as the grumpy Herb Brooks. John J. O'Connor of the
New York Times said "
Miracle on Ice is a fine example of the inspirational sports film. Nothing is said of the many career disappointments suffered by the players since the Olympics, but this film is meant to recapture an extraordinary moment, which it does." O'Connor did however also say that
Miracle on Ice was sprinkled liberally with silly bits of business and ludicrous efforts to inject some romance into the scenario. For instance, every so often, a beautiful woman would suggestively approach one of the players, only to disappear quickly as, under Herb Brooks' orders. O'Connor added that outside of Mike Eruzione and Jim Craig, the rest of the team is just a collection of faces passing quickly before the cameras, identified only by the names on the backs of their uniforms. Meanwhile, O'Connor argued that other characters such as Patti Brooks as the loyally supportive and enthusiastic wife and Jim Craig's father, Donald (a devoted fan carrying a religious medal for good luck), are little more than plot conveniences. 33 years later, Victor Mather of the
New York Times said that while
Miracle on Ice was "Much less inspired than its successor (2004's
Miracle), it still delivers a chill or two at its climax."
Entertainment Weekly gave
Miracle on Ice a
B-, saying "Watching
Andrew Stevens and Steve Guttenberg trying to make like hockey players is itself faintly chilling. But the on-ice action is the real thing, and the thrills have not diminished a bit." ==Historical inaccuracies==