The following is a visual summary of the past results of Miss Idaho titleholders at the national Miss America pageants/competitions. The year in parentheses indicates the year of the national competition during which a placement and/or award was garnered, not the year attached to the contestant's state title.
Placements •
1st runners-up: Karen Herd (1972) •
Top 10: Marlene Coleman (1961), Nina Forest (2019) •
Top 15: Louise Fletchner (1939), Kylee Solberg (2017) •
Top 16: Sierra Sandison (2015)
Awards Preliminary awards •
Preliminary Lifestyle and Fitness: Kristine Phillips (1968)
Non-finalist awards •
Non-finalist Talent: Carene Clark (1958), Bonnie Leila Baird (1959), Judith Steubbe (1965), Rhonda Hammond (1966), Karen Ryder (1969), RaNae Peterson (1977), Kimberly Jensen (1979), Stephanie Kambitsch (1982), Elaine Pack (1984), Kendra Ruwe (1991), Sadie Quigley (2008), Whitney Wood (2013),
Kalie Wright (2016) •
Non-finalist Interview: Rebecca Trueblood (1990), Elizabeth Barchas (2005)
Other awards • '''
America's Choice:'''
Sierra Sandison (2015) •
Miss Congeniality: Grace Zimmerman (2020) •
Four Points Award: Genevieve Nutting (2012), Whitney Wood (2013), Sarah Downs (2014) •
Louanne Gamba Instrumental Award: Whitney Wood (2013) •
Quality of Life Award Winners: Tracey Brown (2006) •
Quality of Life Award 1st runners-up: Brooke Gambrell (1996), Elizabeth Barchas (2005) •
Quality of Life Award Finalists: Whitney Wood (2013) •
Women in Business Scholarship Award Finalists: Grace Zimmerman (2020) ==Winners==