Contemporary A reviewer for
The Moving Picture World, October 19, 1912, after a brief sketch of the plot, declared Miss Robinson Crusoe "a highly artistic picture and, where it fails to be so, it is nevertheless effective, and makes a very desirable offering." The reviewer adds that LaBodie's "handling of a huge rattlesnake makes a most startling scene." A critic at
The Morning Telegraph, October 13, 1912, noted the tropical settings in the film. Allowing that "the photoplay is well carried out to the end," the review concluded by informing readers that "A reel and a half are necessary for the tale."
Retrospective appraisal Literature and film critic
Edward Wagenknecht declares that
Miss Robinson Crusoe "does not deserve to be memorialized; it must have been a terrible picture." Wagenknecht, who viewed the film upon its release when he was a 12-year-old boy, recalls the film from his juvenile perspective: ==Notes==