Reviews in the American press were generally favorable, though some expressed reservations. For
Rolling Stone, David Handelman summed up Richman's preceding mid-1980s output as "spotty, but always with shining moments"; he expressed a similarly mixed reaction to
Modern Lovers 88, finding some tracks "honest and winning" while others "wear thin fast".
Creem reviewer Craig Zeller wrote that "a lot of these songs do coast on minor melodies and self-borrowings a little too often but—as usual—Jonathan's engaging manner pulls you in." In the
Boston Globe, David Emerson likened Richman to "a sincere/silly cross between
Wally Cleaver and
Pee Wee Herman ... In Richman's world, familiar joys are to be praised and new ones explored. An artist in the process of maturing? Not really. A singer with heart who's not ashamed to still have fun? You bet." Other American critics were less reserved with their praise. "Happily," wrote
Spins Jim Daly, "
Modern Lovers 88 finds Richman firmly back on track. The 11-song album can be compared to a picture drawn by a first-grader, which is then proudly brought home, and admired not for its technical acumen but for its purity of spirit." David Okamoto of the
St. Petersburg Times compared it to "a sloppy finger-painting, where technique comes in second to the feelings being expressed", and said an open-minded listener would "discover that
Modern Lovers 88 is just a warm, fun throwback to a simpler time, when music was nothing but a form of personal expression." Jim Zebora of the
Record-Journal said the album showed Richman to be "one of rock's wonders" and highlighted the immediacy of his vocal performance, writing that "he's got guts to be so far out in front, unprotected by anything but his sincerity." In the
Austin American-Statesman, James Nold Jr. praised
Modern Lovers 88 for encapsulating what he saw as Richman's finest qualities as a performer and songwriter, which he felt overcame flaws like a lack of ambition or propensity for childishness: Critical consensus among reviewers in the British press was also complimentary. Writing for
Record Mirror,
Ian Dickson said Richman "still hasn't grown up and, having grooved along to
Modern Lovers 88, I hope he never will", while also claiming the songs to be "a lot more astute than you might imagine" in light of their sometimes juvenile subject matter.
NMEs Len Brown detected "an original spring in his steps, a daft charm in his innocence" that he compared favorably to the late 1970s Modern Lovers lineup, and wrote, "There's something reassuring about Jonathan's prolonged adolescence, something we can all depend on; if he ever grew up it would be as disturbing as
Morrissey taking up wind-surfing. For while the world gets older and uglier Jo-Jo gets simpler 'n' sweeter, younger all the time." Pete Clark at
Hi-Fi News & Record Review wrote that "
88 sees Richman further refining his muse, casting aside some of his more icky anthropomorphisms and descending still further into deep joy ... If there's a child in you waiting to get out, here's the 24-hour pass." A print advertisement for the album, run by Demon Records, quoted further plaudits published in
City Limits and
Melody Maker.
Retrospective appraisal In record guides of 1990s and 2000s, rock critics often dismissed
Modern Lovers 88 as just another album in a mid-career slump for Richman. The album received middling scores in
The Rolling Stone Album Guide, the
Spin Alternative Record Guide, and
MusicHound Rock: The Essential Album Guide. Critics usually lumped it alongside his other 1980s records, which were glossed as lackluster, dated in style, or too eccentric for the uninitiated listener. None of the aforementioned guides differentiated the album from any of his other 1980s records, with the exception of the third edition of the
Rolling Stone Album Guide, which dubiously noted the album's reputation as a comeback among Richman's
cult following. Rock critic
Robert Christgau omitted the album altogether from his ''
Record Guide: The '80s''. By contrast,
AllMusic's
Richie Unterberger deemed the album "one of his better '80s efforts," praising its stripped-down "summertime campfire feel" and singling out "I Love Hot Nights", "California Desert Party", and "Gail Loves Me" among the "best uptempo tunes" in Richman's catalog. In the
New Trouser Press Record Guide, Ira Robbins praised it as a "magical" and "all-too-brief set" with songs that "convert the essential ingredients of '50s R&B into airy but exciting dance-rock as only the Modern Lovers can."
Modern Lovers 88 received a highly favorable reassessment in the anthology ''Lost in the Grooves: Scram's Capricious Guide to the Music You Missed'' by critic Jacqueline Zahas, who said the album had become "stranded in his long catalog" but "reminds us that Jonathan's not just sweetness and whimsy, but a visionary, stubbornly working out his own unique brand of rock and roll." The editors of the
Scram anthology went further, calling for a broad reappraisal of Richman's solo efforts from the period: British music critic
Alexis Petridis later referred to
Modern Lovers 88 as one of the records from Richman's "80s
purple patch". In 2018,
NME included the album on a list of "100 cult albums to hear before you die" with a blurb written by
Win Butler of
Arcade Fire, who praised Richman's lyricism on songs such as "I Love Hot Nights". ==Track listing==