All About Jazz's Mark Corroto stated: Hargrove has reached a jazz pinnacle, his story has made the cover of jazz magazines and this
With Strings record is his parade. [...] A first-class recording and beautiful sound mark Hargrove's sophistication as an artist. He has painted the final scene to a very heartbreaking melancholy film in my mind." Richard S. Ginell of
AllMusic wrote: "The leadoff track 'You Go to My Head' is gorgeous; Hargrove plays soulfully and inwardly, and pianist Larry Willis's arrangement is emotionally satisfying without being cloying. However, the disc continues on and on in this fashion, one tune seeming to blend into another, one arrangement sounding like the next... Hargrove tries his own hand at string arranging on his composition 'Natural Wonders'; the results are noticeably less sophisticated and not as richly-harmonized as the others on the disc. [...] Hargrove's undoubted sincerity and musicality go only a limited distance over the 68-minute span of the CD before simply repeating themselves out." A brief by
BBC Radio 3 declared that the album proves Hargrove "is the first rank of jazz ballad players". Doug Ramsey, writing for
JazzTimes, noted of the album: "His variations maintain the mood and intent of the originals, brilliantly so on 'How Insensitive' and 'I Fall in Love Too Easily.' [...] Hargrove arranged 'Natural Wonders,' which holds its own in the company of classics". Tim Perlich of Toronto's
Now newspaper described the album as "a lushly orchestrated set of romantic ballads". In a
New York Times interview with journalist Marcus J. Moore, trumpeter
Ambrose Akinmusire praised the album's track "Always and Forever", commenting that it "might be the deepest ballad performance I've ever heard on trumpet", and added: "The strings are lush and not in the way – just enough to hold Roy. [...] His phrasing is quiet and patient, like he's talking to himself and letting us eavesdrop. Every note holds something: pain, humor, the blues, urgency. [...] That kind of vulnerability isn't always safe for us. But Roy made it cool." == Track listing ==