Booklist called
Monster Island "a fantastic zombie novel", and wrote: "There are many layers to this zombie apocalypse, and this book just gets things rolling." In a review that was chiefly positive,
Publishers Weekly praised the book's visceral impact, describing the plot as "inventive and exciting". They also commended Wellington for his knowledge of New York and the
Monster Island's touches of dark humor, but felt that he displayed selective memory at times in composing the narrative.
The Washington Post gave the novel a strongly negative review, criticizing it for a lack of background information on the origin of the zombie menace, as well as what the reviewer considered to be nonsensical or absent motives for many characters' actions. ==References==