Wanderers SC In September 2014, Dyer signed with
New Zealand Premiership side
Wanderers SC. Dyer made his competitive debut for Wanderers in the opening round of the
2014–15 ASB Premiership against
Waitakere United in a 3–2 loss. That season, he made a total of nine league appearances for Wanderers.
Eastern Suburbs In 2016, Dyer signed with
Eastern Suburbs, making seventeen appearances that season and scoring five goals. Following his participation at the
U-20 World Cup, Dyer trialed with several European sides including
Arendal,
Vejle Boldklub and
Crewe Alexandra.
Second spell at Eastern Suburbs In 2017, Dyer returned to
Eastern Suburbs and made fifteen appearances that season, scoring four goals.
Manukau United On 30 March 2018, Dyer signed for
Kevin Fallon's newly formed
Manukau United in New Zealand's
NRFL Premier.
Florø On 25 July 2018, Dyer signed with
Norwegian First Division side
Florø SK. That season, he made seven appearances, scoring one goals as Florø was relegated to the
Second Division. He made his debut on August 16 against
Cavalry FC. After the
2021 CPL season, Valour announced they had exercised Dyer's contract option, keeping him at the club through 2022. In December 2022, Valour announced that Dyer would be departing the club.
FC Tulsa On 22 December 2022, Dyer signed with
USL Championship side
FC Tulsa. On 15 March 2024, FC Tulsa announced the mutual termination of Dyer's contract.
Vancouver FC In March 2024, Dyer returned to the Canadian Premier League, joining
Vancouver FC. In August 2024, he was loaned to
Pacific FC for the remainder of 2024 in a loan swap, with
Ayman Sellouf heading to Vancouver FC on loan for the same duration.
Galway United On 12 January 2025, Dyer signed for
League of Ireland Premier Division club
Galway United. He was named
League of Ireland Player of the Month for April 2025. He scored 10 goals in 20 appearances before
Derry City met the buyout clause in his contract in June 2025, but he declined their contract offer. Dyer finished
fifth top goal scorer in the Premier Division that season, despite leaving halfway through.
Phnom Penh Crown On 19 July 2025, it was announced that Dyer had signed for
Cambodian Premier League side
Phnom Penh Crown after they had met the €60,000 buyout clause in his Galway United contract. ==International career==