Throughout its circulation,
Mother Jones magazine has been the subject of criticism regarding the editorial position of the staff, exploitation of interns, misinterpreting data about homeless people,
Michael Moore, who had owned and published the
Flint, Michigan-based
Michigan Voice for ten years, followed English and edited
Mother Jones for several months, until he was fired for disputed reasons.
Matt Labash of
The Weekly Standard reported this was for refusing to print an article that was critical of the
Sandinista human rights record in Nicaragua—a view supported by
The Nation columnist
Alexander Cockburn, but denied by Hochschild and others at the magazine. Moore believes that he was fired because of his defiant reaction to the publisher's refusal to allow him to cover a story on the GM plant closings in Flint. Moore also felt that he did not have a chance to shape the magazine, and that many of the articles that were printed during his time as editor were articles that had already been commissioned by Deirdre English. After being fired in 1986, Moore sued
Mother Jones for $2 million for wrongful termination, but settled with the magazine's insurance company for $58,000—$8000 more than the initial offering. In December 2013,
Mother Jones was criticized for its labor practices regarding the employment of interns, as part of the Ben Bagdikian Fellowship Program. The program allowed college students to enroll as "fellows" who would receive a monthly stipend of $1,000 while working for the magazine in
San Francisco. Writer Charles Davis of
Vice criticized this practice as exploitative noting that "a fellow [working] at
Mother Jones earns less than $6 an hour in a state, California, that just decided to raise the minimum wage to $10." Following the publication of the article,
Mother Jones announced that it would reform its budget to provide fellows with equivalent to California's minimum wage. According to Davis, a former intern alleged that they were advised by the company's human resources department to register for food stamps. The magazine was subject of controversy regarding an October 2016 article about
white supremacist figure
Richard B. Spencer titled, "Meet the Dapper White Nationalist Riding the Trump Wave", which was interpreted as presenting Spencer in a positive light in contrast to his promotion of violent, racialist views. In response to the controversy,
Mother Jones deleted a
tweet promoting the article, in addition to removing the word "dapper" from the title of the article. The 2017 video game
Wolfenstein II: The New Colossus featured a newspaper article entitled "Meet The Dapper Young KKK Leader With A Message Of Hope". Video game website
Kotaku said the addition was "clearly a shot at
Mother Jones and any other media outlet who decides to start getting cutesy about
white supremacy". In 2022, journalist and media critic
Jesse Singal defended the story as a valuable example of investigative journalism and characterized its critics as misinformed, writing that "it's almost impossible to imagine any reasonable reader confusing it for a puff piece." Singal cited the social media response to the article as an example of what he saw as an increasing problem of slander against journalists, concluding that "the Twitter gauntlet consistently destroys good journalism." In August 2017, journalist and
Mother Jones contributor
Glenn Greenwald criticized an article published by the magazine titled "Are People Disgusted By the Homeless?" by Kevin Drum, which Greenwald asserts uses dehumanizing stereotypes of homeless people. Kevin Drum would again be a subject of controversy in July 2019, when Naomi Lachance of
Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting criticized Drum's handling of the
Wayfair Walkout in a blog post titled "I Don't Understand the Wayfair Walkout". The Wayfair Walkout was a planned protest action taken by workers and employees of the furniture company to express their opposition to the companies contracting with ICE and other government agencies involved in detainment of suspected undocumented immigrants. In response to news of the walkout, Drum wrote, "But isn't our whole complaint that these kids are being treated badly? Shouldn't we want companies to sell the government toothpaste and soap and beds and so forth? What am I missing here?" In response to these comments, Lachance wrote "In a cruel and violent world, full of exponentially increasing climate change, natural disasters, food shortages and wars, people cross borders in search of a place where they have a sliver of a chance to survive. That determination for life should be celebrated, not criminalized. Drum has an attitude toward immigrants that is xenophobic and deeply embarrassing for
Mother Jones." In late 2017, journalist and columnist
David Corn was accused of
workplace sexual harassment by former staffers who alleged the columnist of engaging "...in inappropriate workplace behavior, including unwanted touching and rape jokes". These allegations were published in numerous newspapers and magazines, including
The Daily Beast and
Politico.
Mother Jones conducted an internal investigation of the accusations, concluding that there was no evidence of misconduct. ==See also==