Critical reception for
Mr. Shivers has been generally positive, with
The Guardian stating that the book was "a startling début, a deft amalgam of thriller, cerebral horror and
American gothic, written with a stark and artful simplicity that complements the examination of struggling humanity pushed to its limits." Common praise for the book centers on Bennett's writing, as
Tor.com's Stefan Raets stated that "If the setting’s what pulled me into the novel, Robert Jackson Bennett’s spectacular prose is what sold me". The setting was also frequently highlighted favorably in reviews, as Michael Dirda of
The Washington Post felt that it was "convincingly bleak" while also praising the titular character and comparing him to
Hannibal Lecter. Barry Forshaw of the
Daily Express also drew comparisons, comparing Bennett to
Stephen King and
John Steinbeck.
SF Signal and the
Historical Novel Society also reviewed the book, with the former stating that while readers familiar with science fiction, horror, and fantasy tropes would find some parts of the book predictable, it was also a "very strong debut novel". Bennett has stated that some readers have complained that the book did not have enough gore or that although it was shelved as horror, that they did not see it as a horror novel. Of this, Bennett has commented that he was "not going to write straight fantasy, or straight horror, or straight anything" as he viewed it as dull. == Awards ==