The events in the tale of Sang Nila Utama are highly symbolic and are unlikely to be sober retellings of historical events. The casting of the crown into the sea, an action imbued with symbolic meaning as "sovereignty" in the Malay world relied strongly on ceremony and attire, could represent the shift of power from Palembang to Singapura as the new centre of power for the Malay kings. Another candidate for the beast mentioned in the
Malay Annals is mythical beast called
janggi told in
Minangkabau legends as a guardian of gold mines. Dark red hair called
rambut janggi, said to be of this mythical beast but probably actually from
orangutans, adorn lances that were kept by the Minangkabaus as heirlooms. Regardless of the exact species of animal, the symbolism of the Asiatic lion as an emblem of power was strongly established through the spread of Buddhist culture in Southeast Asia. With regards to the historicity of settlement on Singapore itself, it remains debated if a 3rd-century Chinese account of a locality named
Pu Luo Zhong refers to the main island of Singapore,
Pulau Ujong. Nevertheless, other settlements such as
Long Ya Men and
Ban Zu on the island of
Dan Ma Xi (assumed to be a transliteration of Temasek), along with their governance by local rulers, are recorded by the
Yuan Dynasty Chinese traveller
Wang Dayuan in his
Daoyi Zhilue and later
Ming Dynasty records.
Identification with Parameswara '' erected on
Fort Canning Hill to memorialise Iskandar Shah, the last Raja of Singapura commonly identified with
Parameswara due to commonalities in their biographies. Although the
archaeology of Singapore has lain rest to the idea that its 14th-century history is wholly fictional, Confusing matters further is that "Parameswara", deriving from the Sanskrit for "Supreme Lord", was a highly popular title amongst contemporary rulers both in mainland and archipelagic Southeast Asia. Parameswara's rule, unlike Sang Nila Utama's, involves deceit and treachery, namely assassinating its local ruler after enjoying his hospitality for nine days, and unlike Sri Tri Buana's illustrious settlement is terminated almost immediately by the Siamese superiors of this murdered chieftain. The conquest of Singapore forces him to flee to the
Malay Peninsula, eventually leading to the establishment of the
Melaka Sultanate; the destruction of Singapore is instead blamed on a king known as Iskandar Shah, the fifth Raja of Singapura and fourth successor to Sang Nila Utama, and the island's conquerors are identified as Javanese of
Majapahit. These differences may reflect ideological differences in their sources; Pires named a "Javanese chronicle" as his source for Parameswara's biography, and is therefore more likely to have transmitted biases among the Majapahit against their Sumatran predecessors in Palembang, whereas the
Malay Annals seek to highlight historical connections between the Kingdom of Singapura and its successor states of the Melaka Sultanate and the
Johor Sultanate, promoting the legitimacy of its contemporary publishers in Johore. It is therefore unclear as to whether Singapore's 14th-15th century archaeology thus reflects five generations' worth of trade and exchange begun by Sang Nila Utama, or the Majapahit world-order and its brief disruption by Parameswara. == Uncertainty over the date of founding ==