Golden Age The concept of a universe and a multiverse in which the fictional stories take place was loosely established during the
Golden Age of Comic Books (1938–1956). With the publication of
All-Star Comics #3 in 1940, the first crossover between characters occurred with the creation of the
Justice Society of America (JSA), which presented the first superhero team with characters appearing in other publications (comic strips and anthology titles) to bring attention to less-known characters. This established the first shared "universe", as all these heroes now lived in the same world. Prior to this publication, characters from the different comic books seemingly existed in different worlds. Later,
Wonder Woman #59 (May 1953) presented DC Comics' first story depicting a parallel "mirror" world.
Wonder Woman is transported to a twin Earth where she meets Tara Terruna, who is exactly like her. Tara Terruna means "Wonder Woman" in the native language of that world. Wonder Woman describes this world as being a twin world existing alongside Earth with duplicates of everyone but with a different development. The concept of different versions of the world and its heroes was revisited in the pages of
Wonder Woman a few times later.
Silver Age '' and the variations of the
Flash inhabiting each Earth, art by Dan Jurgens and Art Thibert. Led by editor
Julius Schwartz and writer
Gardner Fox, DC Comics' superheroes were given a "reboot" with the publication of
Showcase #4 in 1956, where a new version of the
Flash made his first appearance. This is considered the beginning period of the
Silver Age of Comic Books. The success of this new Flash led to the creation of new incarnations of the Golden Age characters who only shared the names and powers but had different secret identities, origins and stories. Later, new versions of other heroes,
Superman,
Batman and Wonder Woman, were also restarted by retelling their origins but keeping their secret identities. Fox, who worked before in the creation of the JSA, where other heroes met for the first time, created the story "
Flash of Two Worlds" in
The Flash #123 (1961), where Barry Allen, the new Flash, is transported to the Earth where the original Flash,
Jay Garrick, existed. To Barry, Jay Garrick's world was a work of fiction as it was in the real world. This story not only presented the encounter of two worlds and the existence of the Multiverse for the first time, but it also presented key features of the Multiverse: all the universes vibrate at a specific frequency which keeps them separated; these "barriers" could be trespassed by "tuning" to that vibration. Because people could also "tune-in" these worlds in dreams, some people wrote comic books with the stories from those worlds they dreamed, which explained why Barry knew about Jay as a fictional character. The success of this story led to the first team crossover between the new
Justice League of America (JLA) and the Golden Age JSA, in the stories "Crisis on Earth-One" (
Justice League of America #21) and "Crisis on Earth-Two" (
Justice League of America #22), published in late 1963. This story arc started the tradition of a yearly crossover between the JLA and the JSA, and established the concept of a Multiverse and the designation of names,
Earth-One being the JLA reality and
Earth-Two the JSA reality. The success of these crossovers spawned publications telling the further stories of the Golden Age heroes in the present-day parting from many of the stories told, thus establishing a more defined continuity for every universe. This concept of parallel Earths with differences in locations, persons and historical events became a very important ingredient within DC Comics' publications. It helped (among other things) to explain continuity errors, to retell and
retcon stories, and to incorporate foreign elements that could actively interact with everything else and allow them to have an "existence". Continuity flaws between the established Earth-Two and several stories from the Golden Age were given separate Earths. "Imaginary" stories and sometime divergences of Earth-One were given also separate realities (such as Earth-B and Earth-A). In addition to the stories appearing mainly in the pages of
JLA that created new Earths, the acquisition of other comic book companies and characters by DC Comics incorporated these new properties as Earths in the Multiverse which would interact several times with the "main" Earths, One and Two; two of the most notable being Earth-S for the
Fawcett Comics characters, and Earth-X for the
Quality Comics characters. By the 1970s, everything that was published or related officially to DC Comics' titles could become part of the Multiverse, although much of it remained largely uncatalogued. The names of the worlds were usually in the format
Earth, hyphen, spelled numeral/letter/name. In the case of worlds with numerals, the "rule" of spelling the number was not always followed, even within the pages of the same issue.
Crisis on Infinite Earths As the 50th anniversary of DC Comics drew near, major events were proposed for the celebration: an encyclopedia (''
Who's Who in the DC Universe'') and a crossover of the ages, characters, and worlds appearing in DC's comics. As told in the letter section of
Crisis on Infinite Earths #1, as the research started in the late 1970s, it became evident that there were many flaws in continuity. The way used to circumvent some of these errors was the "Multiple Earths", which also showed a chaotic nature that brought even more continuity problems that were not easily explained or were simply left unexplained. Examples of this included: 1) the
Black Canary of Earth-One being the daughter of the original Black Canary, who was a resident of Earth-Two, and 2) the existence of Golden Age comic books on Earth-One and the people not noticing that some of the characters in those comic books existed in "real life". In addition, many universes had multiple alternate timelines, such as
Kamandi and the
Legion of Super-Heroes both being from Earth-One. Writer
Marv Wolfman took this crossover event as an opportunity to reform all the fictional universe of DC Comics to avoid further continuity errors and update the DC characters to modern times. The whole Multiverse is destroyed except for five Earths (the
Silver Age's Earth-One, the
Golden Age's Earth-Two,
Charlton Comics' Earth-Four,
Fawcett Comics' Earth-S and
Quality Comics' Freedom Fighters' Earth-X). Later, the universe is recreated as one single universe with elements of the surviving five. The crossover event
Convergence (2015) officially retconned the events of
Crisis after heroes in that series went back in time to prevent the collapse of the Multiverse.
Modern Age DC Comics After the conclusion of
Crisis on Infinite Earths, the concept of a single Universe containing most elements of the "surviving Earths" was established and heavily enforced to avoid the continuity problems of the Multiverse. However, alternate realities that affected the new DC Universe appeared very quickly. In
Superman (vol. 2) #8, a Universe inside the Universe was revealed to have been created to preserve the Legion of Super Heroes' 30th century in New Earth. This world was used to allow
crossovers with certain characters of the Legion of Super-Heroes and recreate characters that otherwise could not exist in the new continuity (such as
Kryptonians, as in the New Earth
Superman was the only survivor of Krypton). Alternate timelines were also used, the most notable event being
Armageddon 2001 in 1991. An
Antimatter Universe existed as well, which had some "reversed" events in a similar way as the former Earth-Three. The Earth within this Universe was called "Earth 2". In addition, there was a
Limbo, where some heroes and characters that could not be brought back to "existence" after the
Crisis on Infinite Earths lived outside the Universe. An important rule in the new DC Universe was that there could only be one timeline, so any change caused by time travelers caused the destruction of their timelines of origin. Changes in the past were often "fixed" or have to comply with the present to prevent continuity errors. Nevertheless, continuity errors appeared. The retold origin of
Hawkman presented errors regarding the existence of the Golden Age version (
Carter Hall) and the Silver Age version (
Katar Hol) in the same continuity without explanation. The interaction of "possible timelines" also created continuity holes. This led to a new crisis to address the problem, titled
Zero Hour: Crisis in Time!. The resulting universe had a slightly re-written story with no continuity errors even though it was acknowledged that reality-shattering events did happen (including
Crisis on Infinite Earths). This Universe kept the concept of one universe, one timeline. Such a timeline was "mapped" from the beginning to the present (1994) at the back cover of
Zero Hour #0 that also included certain key dates in the future. The need to publish stories outside the strict DC Universe continuity led to the creation of certain DC
imprints. Stories that set DC characters in different situations after the
Crisis on Infinite Earths, were published by DC Comics under the
Elseworlds imprint. None of these stories were ever intended to be included in the "real" continuity of the DC Universe. Certain characters were reinvented in a mature context and were published under the
Vertigo imprint. Most of the times, the characters depicted within the Vertigo imprint had no relation to the original DC Universe's versions, nor did the events have influence over the new Universe. Later, under a special publishing deal with
Milestone Media, DC Comics published a new series of comic books that told the stories of the heroes living in
Dakota City, formed mostly by African American superheroes and other minorities. These characters lived in a universe separated from the DC Universe (known as the Dakotaverse or Milestone Universe). The event
Worlds Collide presented one of the first modern intercompany crossovers within the established continuity of the Universes instead of being "imaginary" and showed that there could be other universes or even multiverses outside the new DC Universe. In a similar way to
Worlds Collide, the crossover event
DC vs. Marvel showed another in-continuity crossover with another reality completely separated from the DC Universe and that has a Multiverse of its own: the universe of Earth-616 in the Marvel Multiverse. The universes were rarely referred to with specific names within the stories but were named in the "Real World" (both officially and unofficially) using the name of the editorial, imprint or even an element in particular. While in the comic books the concept of a "real" Multiverse was avoided, the Multiverse played an important role in cartoon series and live-action shows. In summary, from 1986 to 1999, everything not happening in the "mainstream" continuity appearing in DC comics was either a non-canonical story or happened in a completely different and separate reality/universe/multiverse. In 1999, the success of Elseworlds'
Kingdom Come and other stories, led to the creation of the concept known as
Hypertime in order to publish crossovers with those characters and the mainstream continuity. This structure gave "existence" to alternate timelines, stories in
Elseworlds, appearances in other media and any other appearance of DC characters in the past. The main timeline or "Central Timeline" was like a river and all of the alternate stories were branches of it. Hypertime was similar to the former Multiverse as it allowed each and every reality ever published to co-exist and interact as most branches tend to return to the original stream (explaining some retcons as well as crossovers). However, all realities existed within only one Universe.
WildStorm Originally, the stories appearing in
WildStorm Productions' comic books occurred in a universe that was part of the Image Universe along with other characters appearing in
Image Comics publications. It was separated from it during the event called "Shattered Image" consolidating the separate WildStorm Universe which had its own multiversal structure. After the purchase of WildStorm by DC Comics, crossovers occurred with the new DC Universe, which were still separated just like Milestone and Marvel.
21st century 52 In 2005, a new universal crisis story arc was published as a way to update once more the superheroes of DC Comics, bring together other "realities" (namely, Milestone and Wildstorm) and bring back the Multiverse, this time with a limited number of Earths instead of an infinite one. During the event
Infinite Crisis, the Universe was "splintered" and the original Multiverse was restored briefly, showing that the entire Hypertime and many other appearances of the DC characters were part of the original Multiverse, including
Tangent Comics which were published 12 years after the Multiverse was no more. In the end of
Infinite Crisis, the multiverse is merged back as a New Earth with a new continuity with many stories re-written and many others from the Modern Age still happening. In parallel,
Captain Atom: Armageddon tells the story of how
Captain Atom of the DC Universe causes the recreation of the Wildstorm Universe upon its destruction (and possibly its Multiverse as well). The recreated universe became part of the newly recreated DC Universe. The aftermath of
Infinite Crisis and
Captain Atom: Armageddon (
52,
Countdown to Final Crisis and
Final Crisis) showed that a new Multiverse was created. The new Multiverse consisted of 52 positive matter universes, an Antimatter Universe and a Limbo. The main continuity still occurred in New Earth (also called Earth-0), Earths 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 10 resembled Earths One, Two, Three, Four, S, and X of the original Multiverse respectively. Earths 13 and 50 were Vertigo and the rebooted Wildstorm Universe, while Earth-17 became the world of a revived post-apocalypse
Atomic Knights after a mid-80s
World War III once more. Many important stories from the Elseworlds imprint were later also given their own alternate Earths within this new Multiverse. In the miniseries,
Milestone Forever, in a similar fashion as
Captain Atom: Armageddon, the events that led to the end of the Dakotaverse and its integration to the new DC continuity are revealed. Most of the stories that were told in Milestone Comics publications now occurred in New Earth and the Dakotaverse ceased to exist as a separated Universe. A naming convention was established and followed this time in the format
Earth, hyphen, numeral, from Earth-0 to Earth-51. Even with a new Multiverse, not every published or related work had an "Earth" within the 52 and there were no in-continuity intercompany crossovers. Taking advantage of the fact that many of these universes were mostly unchronicled or merely glimpsed and that
Final Crisis also changed the Multiverse slightly, many stories featuring alternate worlds and their interactions were published, which led certain inconsistencies and retcons to appear, such as Earth-1 being originally a "mirror" of Earth-One and later being the reality of
J. Michael Straczynski's
Superman: Earth One or Earth-16 being the home of an alternate Superman/
Christopher Kent, the home of the
Super-Sons, and later the reality of the
Young Justice TV series. Also, some universes appearing in the new continuity were never given a proper place within the 52 Universe, such as Prime-Earth.
The New 52 The new restored universe with only 52 worlds opened myriad possibilities for new stories and crossovers with different versions of heroes interacting with the main versions of heroes as well as the stories resulting from the new integrated characters from Milestone and Wildstorm. However, it became chaotic in just five years. Many stories and situations of other Universes were not followed well. The number designations could be completely disregarded from story to story and some universes were recreated over and over. In addition, as most of the history of the Modern Age was still being the main continuity, younger readers could not follow the stories of the mainstream versions of the DC heroes, just as had happened prior to the original
Crisis on Infinite Earths. In order to overcome these new problems, a new event was created to restart the DC Comics' Universe. In the
Flashpoint miniseries (May–September 2011), the Flash alters the timeline of Earth-0 creating a ripple effect that affected several past events, Earth-13 (Vertigo Universe) and Earth-50 (new Wildstorm Universe). Similar to the result of
Crisis on Infinite Earths, a new mainstream Earth is created from the former three, with a whole new history. Most of the stories have been retold anew but certain events of New Earth remain (such as
Batgirl being crippled by the
Joker). Since it was established after
Infinite Crisis that if something ever happened to the main Universe, the whole Multiverse could be affected as well, thus a new Multiverse of 52 worlds was also recreated. This new Multiverse is called
The New 52. This time, not all universes were revealed right away, only a couple were revealed in the first two years of
The New 52. In addition, in a similar fashion as the Elseworlds logo would appear in comics that did not occur in the "real" continuity, the logo
THE NEW 52! would only appear in publications with stories occurring in the new continuity, while those taking place outside of this new continuity (such as
Smallville Season Eleven or the
Batman Beyond universe) would not bear this distinction. At first it seemed that there was not going to be a naming convention for the Earths as it happened with the 52. The mainstream continuity was known as Prime Earth, although it was not a similar world to the real world as Earth-Prime was.
J. Michael Straczynski's re-envisioning of Superman and
Geoff Johns' reimagining of Batman were released as part of a series called
Earth One. In Grant Morrison's
The Multiversity (2014–2015), the Earths are named in the same format as in the former 52 Multiverse (Earth-6, Earth-7, Earth-8 etc.). Morrison intended for
The Multiversity to reveal remaining universes of The New 52 multiverse, and the underlying structure for the multiverse was revealed in a detailed map in the back of several comic books, for which an interactive online version was maintained and updated on the DC Comics website. In addition, the sixth issue of
The Multiversity constituted a 'guidebook' to the worlds of the current DC multiverse and was published in January 2015.
Convergence and DC Rebirth In October 2011,
Dan DiDio posted on his
Facebook page that in The New 52, the three previous "crises" did not occur in this new continuity, but other events such as
Zero Hour still happened, without ending in a crisis/reboot. However, writers continued to make references to the crises, and the full history of the structure of the DC Multiverse, detailing previous crisis events, was given in
Grant Morrison's
The Multiversity (2014–2015) limited series. The
Convergence (2015) crossover event later explored this concept within the DCU. This miniseries brought back several heroes from the ages of DC Comics that were obliterated by the crisis events. They were trapped by a godlike incarnation of
Brainiac outside of time (or Vanishing Point as this "place" is called). At the end of the crossover, Brainiac sent these heroes back to their own timelines, and also successfully sent
Zero Hour Hal Jordan, pre-
Flashpoint Superman and other heroes back to the events of
Crisis on Infinite Earths so that the collapse of the Multiverse could be averted. From July 2015 onwards, The New 52 marking ended with the continuation of several publications and new others that did not necessarily take place within
The New 52 multiverse. Advertised as
DC YOU (a pun of DCU or DC Universe and the phrase "it's about you, the fans" appearing in the advertisements), DC now has an "open doors" policy to continuity, granting writers greater freedom to explore stories set outside the established New 52 Multiverse continuity, as well as to revisit other characters and concepts from DC's history as the conclusion of
Convergence suggested that although the core 52 universe that now exists is the evolution of the multiverse, all the worlds still exist in some form. This was confirmed by
Convergence writer Jeff King, who stated that the reconstituted Multiverse is infinite and there may be more than one Multiverse. The 2016
DC Rebirth initiative returned the original
Wally West to Earth from the
Speed Force and reveals that time has been stolen from his friends' memories, and the Superman of the pre-
Flashpoint world, stranded in the new timeline following
Convergence, assumes the role of that Earth's Superman. In
Action Comics #976, the pre-
Flashpoint and
New 52 Supermen's histories are merged.
Peter Tomasi explained that "the events of
Action #976 reset and reshape the entire Superman timeline. Where there had been two Superman, their realities have now been fused into one timeline with just one of them".
Dark Nights and Doomsday Clock It is revealed in
Death Metal that the New 52 was created by
Perpetua, discovered by
Doctor Manhattan in
Doomsday Clock as he experimented with timelines, manipulating events to prevent many
Golden Age heroes from gaining their powers and continually moving Superman to different points in the timeline, resulting in superheroes emerging later in history. After a confrontation with Superman, Manhattan attempts to erase his tampering and restore the Pre-Flashpoint and Pre-Crisis multiverses, as well as elements he had previously removed from the history of Earth-0 such as the
Justice Society of America and
Legion of Superheroes. It is later revealed that he failed, only managing to destabilise the timestream further as it attempted to accommodate events from previous versions of reality. Meanwhile,
Dark Nights: Metal, written by
Scott Snyder, introduced the concept of the Dark Multiverse, a multiverse below the main DC Multiverse. A being named Barbatos launches an attack from the Dark Multiverse on reality, spearheaded by a force of villainous versions of Batman led by
The Batman Who Laughs. The invasion is defeated, but the
Source Wall is cracked and the Batman Who Laughs manages to escape into the main DC Universe. The story is continued in
Justice League. In Snyder's run on
Justice League, the crack in the Source Wall allows the Totality, a small meteorite bearing immense power, to enter the Multiverse from the Source beyond.
Lex Luthor retrieves the Totality and eventually frees Perpetua, the creator of the Multiverse. Despite the heroes' best efforts they are ultimately defeated. At the end of
Justice League #39, the defeated League are saved from destruction by the Quintessence, who grant them the power necessary to fight Perpetua. The team run into a portal for the final battle, but this conflict is not shown and from there
Justice League follows the team on other adventures, written by new writers. In the special event comic
Year of the Villain: Hell Arisen, the Batman Who Laughs joins with Perpetua. The resolution to the Perpetua story arc was advertised in
Justice League #39 as "The Encore", which would eventually be published as
Dark Nights: Death Metal. Published roughly contemporaneously, a six-issue miniseries titled
Flash Forward follows Wally West being enlisted by a cosmic being known as Tempus Fuginaut to stop an incursion of the Dark Multiverse. At the end of the series, Wally sits in the Mobius Chair, gaining omniscience and residual power from Dr. Manhattan. In an epilogue published in
The Flash #750, Wally surveys the timestream and notices multiple
contradictions and inconsistencies within history, the result of Manhattan's tampering with time. This was originally intended to lead into the
Generations miniseries and a reboot of the Multiverse termed "5G", which would have fixed all of DC's publishing history into a single coherent continuity, stretching from
World War II to the present day, with stories going forward focussing on new characters or aged versions of current ones. "A Brave New World", intended to be the first story set in this continuity, was published in
Wonder Woman #750. This reboot was cancelled due to delays caused by the
COVID-19 pandemic and the firing of publisher Dan DiDio, who was the main architect of 5G. The original plans for 5G were recycled into the
Future State event, which followed
Dark Nights: Death Metal.
Dark Nights: Death Metal and its companion comics act as a conclusion to
Dark Nights: Metal,
Flash Forward and Scott Snyder's run on
Justice League. Perpetua destroys much of the Multiverse while the Batman Who Laughs reshapes Earth-0 according to his whims, creating the Metalverse. The Batman Who Laughs successfully steals Wally's new power, becoming a godlike being known as the Darkest Knight. He kills Perpetua and creates his own Multiverse of twisted worlds called "The Last 52".
Wonder Woman gains the power necessary to fight him and eventually destroys him in the Death Sun at the end of time. The Multiverse is once again recreated by higher beings from the Source, with Wonder Woman ascending alongside them to protect it. The New 52/Rebirth multiverse is restored largely as it was prior to the events of
Dark Nights: Death Metal. As well as this, a new infinite web of multiverses appears, the Multiverse developing into an Omniverse. It is established that all events in DC's publishing history have occurred within this new Omniverse, with characters gaining the memories of all their prior incarnations.
Dark Crisis and Flashpoint Beyond Infinite Frontier reveals that awareness of prior incarnations is widespread but not ubiquitous. It also identifies Multiverse 2 as the "corpse" of the pre-Crisis Multiverse.
Dark Crisis calls the Omniverse into question, and adds infinite Earths taken from Multiverse 2 into the Orrery of Worlds, expanding it to contain infinite Earths. Concurrently with
Dark Crisis,
Flashpoint Beyond reveals that the Omniverse and Hypertime exist alongside each other as parts of a larger Divine Continuum, with the Omniverse corresponding to Space and Hypertime corresponding to Time. It also organizes previous Crisis events into Omniversal Crises and Hypertime Crises, with the "Crisis on Infinite Earths", "Infinite Crisis", "Final Crisis", "Multiversity", "Dark Nights", and "Dark Crisis" being Omniversal Crises and "Zero Hour", "the Kingdom", "Flashpoint/New 52", "Convergence", "DC Rebirth/Doomsday Clock", and "Flashpoint Beyond" and "
The New Golden Age" being Hypertime Crises. ==Fictional history and structure==