Critical response The game received "generally favorable reviews" on all platforms except the PSP version, which received "average" reviews, according to the
review aggregation website
Metacritic.
Famitsu gave it a score of one nine, two eights, and one seven for a total of 32 out of 40.
GamePro said that the PlayStation 2 and Xbox versions "[retain] the Gold Glove for controls, but the competition has made up ground."
GameZone gave the PlayStation 2 and Xbox versions each a score of 9.3 out of 10, with Angelina Sandoval calling the former console version "the most solid and wonderfully addictive ballgame on the PS2. With various improvements and some very neat additions to the game, there's just no denying the fact that this is the closest to baseball gaming heaven we'll come this year"; and Eduardo Zacarias saying of the latter console version, "With great modes, gorgeous graphics and near perfect controls this one will no doubt be the franchise we turn to when we want a baseball game true to the sport itself." Natalie Romano gave the GameCube version 9.2 out of 10, calling it "the deepest, most impressive ballgame that's just too addictive." Michael Lafferty gave the PC version nine out of ten, saying, "You can learn to read pitches, fine-tune the single-player controls to give you more room for error or tighten them up to make each pitch a challenge." Romano later gave the PSP version 8.3 out of 10, saying that it "might not feel like the complete package the console version offers, but it's still one of the most genuinely enjoyable and solid ballgames on the PSP."
Computer Games Magazine gave the PC version three-and-a-half stars out of five, saying, "While the AI is good on the field, it's terrible in the front office."
Awards The game was given an award for the best sports video game of 2005 from
X-Play. It was named by
GameSpot as the Best Console Game of February 2005 in Review. The PC version was a finalist for the "Best Sports Game" award at the 12th Annual
PC Gamer Awards, which went to
Tiger Woods PGA Tour 06. The game held the 98th spot on
IGNs reader's choice top 100 games. In May 2013 the game ranked fourth on a "Best sports video games" list by
ESPN.
Sales By July 2006, the game had sold 1 million units and earned $29 million in the U.S.
NextGen ranked it as the 55th highest-selling game launched for the PlayStation 2, Xbox or GameCube between October 2000 and July 2006 in that country. Combined sales of the
MVP Baseball games released in the 2000s reached 3.5 million units. ==Legacy==