Critical reception for the series has been mostly positive. Newsarama called it a "masterful bit of horror". Comic Book Resources panned
Nailbiter's first issue, as they felt that the work did not live up to its premise's potential despite good coloring and artwork. In contrast, IGN praised
Nailbiter #1, stating that it was "an impressive and eerie debut that's sure to turn your sweetest dreams into the stuff of nightmares". Flickering Myth has written predominantly negative reviews for later issues in the series, criticizing it for its pacing and story lines.
Bloody Disgusting gave mostly favorable critical reviews.
Nailbiter was awarded "Best Horror Comic" by USA Today in both 2014 and 2015. It was also the #1 comic on Horror Talks "Best of 2015." ==References==