Working towards Confederation,
Canada's founders deliberated on the official title for their new country, primarily between the "Kingdom of Canada" or the "Dominion of Canada". it is noted that the following names were considered for the union of
British North America: "The United Colony of Canada", "the United Provinces of Canada", and "the Federated Provinces of Canada". Ewart was also an ardent advocate for the formation of "the
Republic of Canada", a position which was rarely expressed in those times.
Kingdom of Canada During the
Charlottetown Conference of 1864,
John A. Macdonald, who later became the first
Prime Minister of Canada, talked of "founding a great
British monarchy," in connection with the
British Empire. He advocated, in the fourth Canadian draft of the
British North America Act (BNA Act), the name "
Kingdom of Canada", in the text is said: Canada's founders, led by Macdonald, wished their new nation to be called the
Kingdom of Canada in order to "fix the monarchical basis of the
constitution". The
governor general at the time,
The 4th Viscount Monck, supported the move to designate Canada a kingdom; however, officials at the
Colonial Office in London opposed this potentially "premature" and "pretentious" reference for a new country. They were also wary of antagonizing the United States, which had emerged from its
Civil War as a formidable military power with unsettled grievances because British interests had sold ships to the
Confederacy despite a blockade, and thus opposed the use of terms such as
kingdom or
empire to describe the new country.
Adoption of Dominion at the end of the nineteenth century. "Dominions" refers to all territories belonging to
the Crown.
Sir Samuel Leonard Tilley,
Premier of New Brunswick, suggested the term
Dominion, inspired by
Psalm 72:8 (from the
King James Bible): "He shall have dominion also from sea to sea, and from the river unto the ends of the earth." This is also echoed in Canada's motto: ' (
Latin for 'from sea to sea'). The term
Dominion had been used for centuries to refer to the lands held by a monarch, and had previously been adopted as titles for the
Dominion of New England and the
Dominion and Colony of Virginia. It continued to apply as a generic term for the major colonial possessions of the British Empire until well into the 20th century; although Tilley and the other Fathers of Confederation broadened the meaning of the word
dominion to a "virtual synonym for
sovereign state". Its adoption as a title for Canada in 1867 served the purpose of upholding the monarchist principle in Canada; in a letter to
Queen Victoria,
Lord Carnarvon stated:The North American delegates are anxious that the United Provinces should be designated as the 'Dominion of Canada.' It is a new title, but intended on their part as a tribute to the Monarchical principle which they earnestly desire to uphold. The Fathers of Confederation met at the
Quebec Conference of 1864 to discuss the terms of this new union. One issue on the agenda was to determine the Union's "
feudal rank" (see
Resolution 71 of the Quebec Conference, 1864). The candidates for the classification of this new union were: ('the Kingdom or Realm of Canada'), ('the Union of Canada'), and ('the Dominion of Canada').
Use of Dominion There are numerous references in
United Kingdom Acts of Parliament to "the Dominion of Canada;" and the
British North America Act, 1867 referred to the formation of "one Dominion under the name of Canada". Section 4 of the BNA Act also declares that: "Unless it is otherwise expressed or implied, the Name Canada shall be taken to mean Canada as constituted under this Act;" this has been interpreted to mean that the
title of the country is simply
Canada. The term "Dominion of Canada" appears in the
Constitution Act, 1871—the usage of which was "sanctioned"—and both "Canada" and "Dominion of Canada" appear in other texts of the period. It also appeared on numerous
Canadian banknotes before 1935. celebrate
Dominion Day 1927, the 60th jubilee of confederation Until the 1950s, the term
Dominion of Canada was commonly used to identify the country in Canadian and British references. As the country acquired
political authority and
autonomy from the
United Kingdom, the
federal government began using simply
Canada on state documents.
Quebec nationalist leaders also objected to
dominion, arguing that it suggested Ottawa would have control over Quebec. Under Prime Minister
Louis St-Laurent, the federal government ended the practice of using "Dominion" in the
Statutes of Canada in 1951. "Dominion" was retired in official names and statements, usually replaced by "federal". The independence of the separate
Commonwealth realms was emphasised after the accession of
Queen Elizabeth II in 1952, when she was proclaimed not just as
Queen of the United Kingdom, but also
Queen of Canada,
Queen of Australia,
Queen of New Zealand,
Queen of South Africa, and of all her other "
realms and territories". With that said, the national holiday of "
Dominion Day" kept that name until 1982, when a
private member's bill to replace the name with
Canada Day that had received first reading in May 1980 was unexpectedly passed in the
House. In the
Senate,
Eugene Forsey and the
Monarchist League of Canada strongly defended the traditional usage. When a
Gallup poll showed 70% of all Canadians favoured the change, the Senate approved the bill without a
recorded vote. The
Canada Act 1982 refers only to
Canada and does not use the term
dominion. No constitutional statute amends this name, nor does any Canadian legal document state that the name of the country is anything other than
Canada. Moreover, official sources of the
United Nations system, international organizations (such as the
Organization of American States), the
European Union, the
United States, and other polities with which Canada has official relations as a state either consistently use
Canada as the only official name, affirm that Canada has no long-form name, or affirm that the formal name is simply
Canada. In a dissenting opinion, Forsey and others, in an essay in
The Canadian Encyclopedia argue that
Dominion of Canada is still the formal name of the country, albeit rarely used now. The terms
Dominion and
Dominion of Canada, although arcane, continued to be used occasionally in Government of Canada publications and educational materials, albeit not in legal or official documents. For instance, in 2008 the Canadian government registered the
Maple Leaf Tartan, designed in 1964, with the
Scottish Tartans Authority. The tartan's alternate name is "Dominion of Canada". These terms have been used in essays to distinguish contemporary (post-1867) Canada from either the earlier Province of Canada or from the even earlier The Canadas and modern history of the Commonwealth. The terms had also been used to distinguish the federal government from the provinces, though in this usage, "federal" has replaced "dominion". For example,
The Canadian Almanac stopped using Dominion of Canada in 1964. ==See also==