Bosley Crowther’s review of
Nancy Goes to Rio critiques MGM’s attempt to mold Jane Powell into a young star similar to Deanna Durbin, placing her under the production of Joe Pasternak and giving her a script reminiscent of Durbin’s films. Crowther describes the movie as a weak remake of ''
It's a Date'' (1940). He criticizes the plot as trivial and lacking strength, though he acknowledges a few pleasant songs and charismatic performances, particularly from Powell, Ann Sothern, and Louis Calhern. The film is praised for musical numbers like "Shine On, Harvest Moon", but is seen as dated and lacking substantial depth. Crowther also points out a misunderstanding in the plot that adds forced humor and notes that, while Powell is talented, she falls short of her potential in this type of film.
Variety describes the movie as a light, sparkling musical with all the typical qualities of the genre, creating a vibrant spectacle. Director Robert Z. Leonard is praised for keeping the film's pace dynamic and avoiding heavy moments, ensuring the story remains escapist. The choreography by Nick Castle is also highlighted for adding visual value to the production. The
St. Petersburg Times lauds
Nancy Goes to Rio, noting its "cheerful songs, harmonious costumes, abundant laughter, and beautiful landscapes," making it a "thoroughly enjoyable" movie. However, the review mentions that the use of Technicolor did not flatter Ann Sothern, making her appear older, nor did it suit Carmen Miranda, who lost some of her charm. On the other hand, Technicolor was beneficial for Louis Calhern, who was older, and Jane Powell, who looked great on screen. Dave Kehr of the
Chicago Reader considers
Nancy Goes to Rio an interesting idea for an MGM musical, with the dynamic of a mother and daughter team of prospectors, but he points out that Robert Z. Leonard’s direction leaves the film lacking in charm. He mentions the cast, which includes Ann Sothern, Jane Powell, Barry Sullivan, Carmen Miranda (whose career was winding down), and Louis Calhern. Kehr also notes that the screenplay by Sidney Sheldon is responsible for the film, which he compares to
The Other Side of Midnight (1950), suggesting that it lacks impact. ==Home media==