In 1999, Toro began a long journey with
A Tale of Two Cities, a musical by
Jill Santoriello. In 2002, she performed the role of
Madame Defarge for the concept recording of the musical. In 2010, she reunited with many members of the Broadway Cast to record the “International Studio Cast Recording”, as well as a DVD of a semi-staged highlights concert of the musical. In 2004, she began to tour with
Jesus Christ Superstar, both while
Sebastian Bach was on the tour and after he left. In 2007, she was cast in the
Broadway musical adaptation of
A Tale of Two Cities in
Sarasota, Florida at the
Asolo Repertory Theatre. She received a 2007
Sarasota Magazine Award for Best Supporting Theatre Actress. Broadway previews in New York began on August 19, 2008, at the
Al Hirschfeld Theatre, with an official opening of September 18. She remained in the show until it closed on November 16, 2008. On November 23, 2008, Toro released her second solo-CD, which was self-titled "Natalie Toro". ==Theatrical Credits==