Due to severe
sea wave erosion during storms, the city hopes to relocate again to a new site from the present site; studies of alternate sites are ongoing. According to the
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, the estimated cost of relocation runs between $95 and $125 million, whereas the
Government Accountability Office (GAO) estimates it to be between $100 and $400 million. The sea ice that was once there, helping to protect the city, has now disappeared. Due to these rising sea levels, maybe people are out of their homes and since resources are becoming scarce, it is leading to overcrowding and poor sanitation. In 2011, Haymarket Books published "Kivalina: A Climate Change Story" by Christine Shearer.
Kivalina v. ExxonMobil Corporation The city of Kivalina and a federally recognized
tribe, the Alaska Native Village of Kivalina, sued
ExxonMobil, eight other oil companies, 14 power companies and one coal company in a lawsuit filed in federal court in
San Francisco on February 26, 2008, claiming that the large amounts of
greenhouse gases they emit contribute to
global warming that threatens the community's existence. The lawsuit estimated the cost of relocation at $400 million. The suit was dismissed by the
United States district court on September 30, 2009, on the grounds that regulating
greenhouse emissions was a political rather than a legal issue and one that needed to be resolved by
Congress and the
Administration rather than by courts.
Kivalina v Teck Cominco In 2004, Kivalina underrepresentation from the co-founder of
Center on Race Poverty and Environment,
Luke Cole, sued Canadian mining company
Teck Cominco, operator of the Red Dog Mine, for polluting its water drinking water source and subsistence fish resources through their discharge of mine waste into the Wulik River. Teck Cominco settled the suit in 2008 by agreeing to build a wastewater pipeline from the mine to the ocean that would bypass discharging into the Wulik River. However, the pipeline was not constructed and the alternative settlement clause was followed.
Kivalina v. US EPA In 2010, the Native Village of Kivalina IRA Council brought suit against the US EPA for failing to adequately address public comments in their permitting of the Red Dog Mine discharge plan under the
National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES). In 2012, the US
Ninth Circuit court upheld the decision of the EPA Appeals Board to not review the permit, citing the insufficiency of the Tribe's argument.
Orange goo On August 4, 2011, it was reported that residents of the city of Kivalina had seen a strange orange goo wash up on the shores. According to the Associated Press, "Tests have been conducted on the substance on the surface of the water in Kivalina. City Administrator Janet Mitchell told the Associated Press that the substance has also shown up in some residents' rain buckets." On August 8, 2011, Associated Press reported that the substance consisted of millions of microscopic eggs. Later, officials of the
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) confirmed that the orange colored materials were some kind of crustacean eggs or embryos, but subsequent examination resulted in a declaration that the substance consisted of
spores from a possibly undescribed species of
rust fungus, later revealed to be
Chrysomyxa ledicola. While the risk of inundation from sea water has always existed, storms caused extensive flooding in 1970, 1976, 2002, 2004, and spurred a village-wide evacuation in 2007. To slow erosion, the
US Army Corps of Engineers conducted a rip-rap revetment project along the tip of the barrier island and adjacent to the airport.
Other climate change impacts In addition to increased flooding from storm surges, bank erosion along the Wulik River causes increased turbidity which affects the city's drinking water source and complicates water treatment. ==Relocation==