Believing he could become a placekicker and gain a full football scholarship, O'Donoghue travelled to
Auburn University to meet
Ralph Jordan, the head coach of the
football team. He had previously been to
Auburn before, attending as a spectator for the
Iron Bowl match. Jordan had him make a
field goal attempt, and after he converted each one successfully, he won the job. O'Donoghue was selected in the fifth round of the
1977 NFL draft by the
Buffalo Bills, but was cut five games into the
1977 season, despite ending a fourteen game losing streak by scoring the sole field goal against the
Atlanta Falcons. effectively sending the Bucs to the
NFC Championship Game against the
Los Angeles Rams. Neither side were able to score a touchdown, but the Bucs were blown out 9–0, with the Rams'
Frank Corral making all three field goals. Head coach
Jim Hanifan had O'Donoghue and
Steve Little, a former first-round pick who had struggled in the NFL, participate in a kicking contest from 25 yards out. Little made nine out of 16 attempts, while O'Donoghue made fourteen, resulting in him becoming the team's starting kicker. Even though he had the support of Hanifan, he ultimately became known for his high-profile missed kicks. In the
1983 season, he missed three field goal attempts in overtime of a
Monday Night Football game against the
New York Giants, resulting in a 20–20 tie. In the last game of the
1984 season against the Redskins, he missed a potential game-winning kick that would have sent his Cardinals to the playoffs. During that season, O'Donoghue tied the long-standing Cardinals record for most points in a season, which at the time was 117. In the
1985 season, he was cut after missing three attempts against the
Houston Oilers. After his career in the NFL, O'Donoghue sold real estate for a few years, then got into car sales. ==Personal life==