Over the decades,
The New American Poetry has grown in stature and reputation. Poetry scholar
Marjorie Perloff labeled the book "the fountainhead of radical American poetics" and added that "many now-classic poems first became known through Don Allen's anthology".
Charles Bernstein said the anthology enabled Americans to "perceive a tradition that was different from the poetry of the 1940s and 1950s put forth by the American Academy in general, and by the
New Critics in particular. The effect of this anthology has been staggering, and has helped to shape poetry since its publication." Ron Silliman called it "unquestionably the most influential single anthology of the last century. It's a great book, an epoch-making one in many ways."
The New American Poetry was also influential in Canada where "it affected the writing of at least one generation of Canadian poets". It was said to have persuaded many Canadian poets to turn away from British influences and toward American models. Because Allen's search for new poetic voices often involved hunting through "fugitive pamphlets and little magazines", he brought newfound interest in America's non-mainstream publishers, some operating with just a
mimeograph machine. Authors Steven Clay and Rodney Phillips said that Allen's book "might well be considered the 'flash point' for the renaissance in literary writing and small press publishing that would flourish within a few short years of its publication", and that "there was no more significant poetry anthology in the second half of the twentieth century". ==Further reading==