"New Frontier" received critical acclaim.
Billboard labeled it a top single pick, with an unspecified writer commenting, "The lyrics are diffuse and unsettling, but Fagen wraps them in a comfortable, shuffling rhythm and layered harmonies for an overall pleasant effect."
The Independent Phil Johnson called the song a "sardonic take on the optimism of America in the
Cold War period," while Laura Sinagra from
The New York Times a "biting
Reagan-era recollection of 60's hope." Jon Matsumoto at the
Los Angeles Times considered it "rhythmically effervescent," feeling it "captured both the anxieties and the innocence of the era." Stewart Mason, writing for
AllMusic, praised the dual sarcasm and nostalgia of Fagen's lyrics, as well as its "easy, bouncy groove", summarizing it as "one of Fagen's most delightful tunes." ==Music video==