AllMusic's Jeremy Ervins praised the record's "bright and intelligent approach to
hard rock" and "mysterious aura", writing "The band's energy seems to be directed toward song craftsmanship; every song flows very nicely and has its own distinct vibe, while sticking to the overall concept of the album. The guitars tends to sound slightly dry and dull from time to time, which can relate to the lack of creative range in the heavy hard rock genre.
New Killer America is obviously intended to quell this obstacle, as it does with much style and grace on most tracks -- especially "Sleep," a very melodic tune that, despite its title, really awakens the senses toward the end of the album." Jeffrey M. Barr of
The Lantern wrote on June 18, 2001 that "the CD is easy to find at the local record shop because of its gross and disturbing cover of an infected toenail. Then there is the music that comes off as loud and intense. And then the band becomes instantly recognizable." Barr said that the track "Goodbye" sounded "[almost] identical to the band
Filter's style of music", adding that "it's an enjoyable song and one of the band's best tracks." In his March 2001 review, Adam Pugh of the
Arizona Daily Wildcat gave it a C rating, writing "Skrape tries to pretend that it has made something new. In reality, it has ripped off the vocals of
Chino Moreno from the Deftones and shamelessly stolen
Korn's guitarists." He added, "the music, despite its 'borrowed' status, is very well done, incorporating punchy rhythms and exhilarating screams. The vocals are clean, something which makes the band sound great, but each song sounds like a band we've all heard before." Dan McQuade of
34th Street also critiqued their lack of originality in his July 2001 review. McQuade added "Skrape has very few things going for them. One thing they are excellent at is album packaging. Their album has to be one of the cleverest uses of packaging ever. While their album packaging is well done, it is sad that the packaging is the best part of
New Killer America."
Legacy The song "What You Say" appeared in the 2001 videogame
Project Gotham Racing, while "Waste" was featured in 2002's
Tony Hawk Pro Skater 4. In 2017,
Spin ranked "Waste" as the 29th greatest nu metal song of all time. ==Track listing==