Five canonical books of the New Testament are ascribed to John and thus called collectively the
Johannine literature: • The
Gospel of John • The
First Epistle of John • The
Second Epistle of John • The
Third Epistle of John • The
Book of Revelation Only in Revelation does the text itself name its author as John; the other Johannine works are ascribed to John only through their attached titles and other external references. Whether or not these attributions have a basis in historical truth—modern scholars vary widely in their opinions about authorship—the question remains of which John each of these attributions refers to. Since antiquity, many have considered the entire Johannine corpus to be the work of a single author, a certain John of Ephesus, whom many identified with the
Apostle John, son of Zebedee. On the other hand, this identification and the authorship of individual works have also been disputed since antiquity. Thus, the reputed authors of the Johannine works are conventionally called more explicitly—without prejudice to the issues of actual authorship and of their mutual identification—as follows.
John the Evangelist The author of the
Gospel has traditionally been termed
John the Evangelist. In the Gospel, the name
John occurs exclusively in reference to
John the Baptist or to the father of
Simon Peter, and without that epithet, though “the sons of Zebedee” (named James and John in the
Synoptics) are also mentioned once. The Gospel even lacks a list of the
Twelve Apostles. The anonymous “
disciple whom Jesus loved” is identified in the closing verses as the one whose testimony the Gospel bears: “This is the disciple who testifies about these things and has written these things.” Ancient sources invariably identify this disciple with the Evangelist, and many modern scholars agree, though others consider that John the Evangelist fashioned the testimony of the Beloved Disciple into a Gospel, as
Mark did for
Peter, or hold on other grounds that the two are not identical. Further identification of the Beloved Disciple and/or the Evangelist with John the Apostle has been variously defended and impugned. Some scholars see the Gospel's “and we know that his testimony is true,” as indicating a second hand, of a hypothetical redactor or some group of elders certifying the work. Bauckham, however, argues that this is simply the “
we of authoritative testimony” of the author himself, used also in the Epistles.
John the Presbyter The short
second and
third epistles are addressed “From the Elder”. On this basis, the author is termed
John the Elder or John the Presbyter (
presbyter being Greek for
elder).
Papias (c. 100) refers to a certain “John the Elder, a disciple of the Lord”, one of the “elders” he had listened to, and from whose sayings he drew in his five-book
Exegesis, now lost. Papias goes on to refer to him simply as “the Elder”. Most see Papias as referring to the same John, at least, who penned the epistles. In later centuries, some saw the address from “the Elder” in the second and third epistles as possibly indicating a different author than the other Johannine works, which cast doubt on their apostolic authority and therefore on their
canonicity.
John of Patmos The author of the
Book of Revelation (also known as the Apocalypse of John) is variously termed
John of Patmos, John the Revelator, John the Divine, or John the Theologian. The text of Revelation identifies its author thus: “I, John, your brother and the one who shares with you in the persecution, kingdom, and endurance that are in Jesus, was on the island called
Patmos because of the word of God and the testimony about Jesus.” Patmos was an island near
Ephesus, and Revelation begins with letters addressed to the
seven churches of Asia, which were Ephesus and other nearby cities.
Dionysius of Alexandria (c. 250) closely criticized Revelation and concluded that it was starkly different from the Gospel and First Epistle (which Dionysius regarded as both the work of John the Apostle) in grammar, style, content, and anonymity, and thus could hardly be the work of the same author, but must have been written by another John, for “there are two monuments in Ephesus, each bearing the name of John.” The ancient scholars who accepted Revelation as authentic, however, invariably identified its author as John the Evangelist. Our earliest and most reliable informant is
Irenaeus (c. 180), who knew John's personal disciples while in
Smyrna. Irenaeus firmly identifies the Revelator with the Evangelist and tells us that he remained with the Church in Ephesus until the time of
Trajan (98–117). The Revelator was still publicly active until the close of
Domitian’s reign (81–96), as Irenaeus says: From Irenaeus’ ambiguous syntax, some later writers inferred that the exile to Patmos occurred under Domitian, though others explicitly ascribed it to
Nero (54–68); modern scholars still debate which is more likely.
Clement of Alexandria, a contemporary of Irenaeus, tells an anecdote of John and the young robber captain, which opens with: So again the Revelator is identified with the Bishop of Ephesus, about whom ancient sources have much to say. ==John of Ephesus==