Grosvenor "proposed a 'free institution,' for the 'literary, scientific, moral, and physical education of both sexes and of all classes of youth.'" The school's
curriculum included
Classical education as well as
agricultural science. The Rev. Grosvenor served as the school's first president, 1849–1851. The college was modeled after
Oberlin, which in 1835 began admitting blacks and in 1837 women. However, New York Central College was the first American college
founded on the principle that all are created equal: black and white, male and female. Qualified Black, female, and
Native American students were all welcome. It was also the first to have African-American professors, in a position filled by three men: first
Charles L. Reason. An unexplained disagreement with Grosvenor led to his departure. His replacement was
William G. Allen, a graduate of the
Oneida Institute, another short-lived school which was a predecessor of the college. After Allen's departure (see below) he was replaced by
George Boyer Vashon, the first African-American graduate of
Oberlin. Reason was the first black college professor in the country. Allen was Professor of Rhetoric and Greek; in 1850, when he was appointed, he was "well known as a lecturer upon the origin, literature, and destiny of the African race." In May 1850 there were over a hundred students enrolled, and college housing being full, students had to take rooms in private houses. There were those in
Syracuse and
Rochester who wished to move the College to their city, but nothing came of it. The Corresponding Secretary of the Trustees, A. H. Benedict, who was also editor of the
Cortland County Express, said in an editorial that no such discussions had taken place, even privately. He suggested that instead of the College relocating to Syracuse, Syracuse should relocate to McGrawville, once "it has done with theatres and their appendages, and her other and numerous sources of corruption.... The moral atmosphere of a city is not congenial to the habits of students, nor the growth of an institution founded on the manusl labor principle, and on equality of sex and condition, as is this college." A few weeks later, another report says that the college received an appropriation of $25,000 (), {{cite book The college's first
commencement was in 1855, with 5 graduates.{{cite news In 1857 Howard W. Gilbert was hired as Professor of Modern Languages. A news article refers to his mastery of French, German, and Italian.{{cite news Also in 1857, the college had a Teachers' Department, training, at the high school level, teachers for the primary grades (
normal school), an Academic Department preparing high school students for college, and a Collegiate Department. There was a class in public speaking. ==Facilities==