The staff at
Variety magazine praised the cast in their review of the film, "Among crime exposes New York Confidential stacks up as one of the better-made entries, thanks to a well-fashioned story and good performances by a cast of familiar names ... Conte does a topnotch job of making a coldblooded killer seem real and Crawford is good as the chairman of the crime board, as is Marilyn Maxwell as his girl friend. Anne Bancroft, showing continuing progress and talent, scores with a standout performance of Crawford's unhappy daughter." The
Chicago Tribune reviewer was uncomplimentary: "The script is thin and tossed together for maximum melodramatic effect and has little to offer other than rapid-fire murder. Either New York elevators are awfully slow or the police awfully fast. In one scene, two gangsters leave a body in a hotel room. It's still undiscovered as they step into the elevator, but before they reach the main floor, the alarm has been given and police surround the building. Speedy, huh? Unless you want your children instructed in the fine points of brutality and bloodshed, leave them at home." Modern critic Dennis Schwartz was disappointed in the film. In 2004 he wrote, "Russell Rouse's
New York Confidential is a crime thriller that is a formulaic exposé of the rackets, and is not quite as good as another such film—
The Enforcer ...
New York Confidential was never exciting, tense or eye-opening. Its narrative was a cliché-driven mob story that was only mildly diverting and even though the performances were energetically delivered, it still tasted like a stale salami sandwich." ==See also==