The team was founded in 1997. Originally known as the New York Broncos, they joined
Super League America, the predecessor to the modern
American National Rugby League, for its inaugural 1998 season. In 2001, the Knights and other teams in the competition departed to form the AMNRL. All teams formed a partnership with teams in
Australia's
National Rugby League. New York formed a partnership with the
Newcastle Knights, who sent them Knights jerseys; the team subsequently changed their name to the New York Knights. The Knights advanced to the AMNRL Grand Final in 2002. A serious
thunderstorm interrupted the game, and the Knights, who were leading perennial champions the
Glen Mills Bulls 18-12, were declared winners. The Knights remained in the AMNRL until it folded in 2014. The following year, they joined the
USA Rugby League, along with other surviving AMNRL clubs. ==Uniform and colors==