The last
streetcars operated in Rochester in 1941, leaving only the
Rochester Subway rapid transit operation to soldier on until 1956.
Rochester Transit Corporation donated car 1246, a Peter Witt-style streetcar, to the
Rochester Museum and Science Center in 1941, but the museum never made any attempt to incorporate the car into a permanent exhibition. Stored outdoors and ravaged by vandals, the car was finally sold for scrap in 1950. Rochester Subway car 60 was donated to the
Rochester Chapter, NRHS in 1956, but having no permanent location, the car was loaned to other organizations outside the region. The roots of the New York Museum of Transportation can be traced back to the
Magee Transportation Museum, a private museum located near Bloomsburg, Pennsylvania, founded by wealthy industrialist Harry Magee, the owner of the Magee Carpet Company. His interest in vintage vehicles of all kinds led him to create a home for antique automobiles and trolleys in the mid-1960s. The museum and trolley rides flourished until the summer of 1972 when flooding caused by
Hurricane Agnes caused extensive damage to the tracks and trolley fleet. Harry Magee died that October, and the collection was sold at auction in 1973. The planned community of Riverton was being developed in
West Henrietta, New York by Henry Hamlin. The cornerstone of this new project was a proposed
light rail line that was to connect Riverton with downtown Rochester constructed along the former
Erie Railroad Rochester Division right of way. A small trolley museum was envisioned as a natural outgrowth of the planned light rail line. With the knowledge that several Rochester area streetcars were preserved at the Magee Transportation Museum, Hamlin made a visit to see what could be salvaged from the shuttered museum. Before his untimely death, Harry Magee had expressed hope that the Rochester streetcars in his collection could one day be returned to New York State to be restored and operate once again. The first car acquired was former
Elmira, Wavery and Corning Railway car 107, as well as a stock of bracket arms and other stock to construct overhead wire.
New York State Railways Rochester and Eastern Rapid Railway car 157 was also acquired in the same deal. Lease of a recently abandoned dairy barn on state agricultural lands in West Henrietta was acquired by Hamlin to house the two cars. Temporary tracks were laid and car 157 was placed inside the barn on October 5, 1973, with car 107 following a month later.
Rochester Transit Corporation sand car 0243 and
Rochester City and Brighton Railroad horse car 55 were brought to the barn site, on loan from the
Rochester Museum and Science Center. A provision charter was issued in 1975, bringing formal organization to the
New York Museum of Transportation. By 1975, the city of Rochester was looking to abandon the remaining western end of the old
Rochester Subway, which was still being used for freight service by both
Penn Central and the
Baltimore & Ohio railroads under contract. The NYMT volunteers were given permission to salvage as much of the track materials as they could for the construction of the rail line circling their campus in West Henrietta. Addition historic vehicles were added to the collection from various sources, and a gift shop, exhibit hall, and gallery were completed inside the old dairy barn.
SEPTA was retiring its fleet of wood-bodied street snow sweepers they inherited from the old
Philadelphia Transportation Company, and NYMT acquired C-130 in January 1975. Designed to run on Philadelphia's five-foot "broad gauge" tracks, NYMT founding director worked to convert the trucks to standard gauge. Nearly all restoration work had been completed on this project, The car has been on display since the 1980s. Construction of the museum's demonstration railroad began in 1976, totaling nearly three-quarters of a mile by 1979, with the help of a CETA grant. By 1980, NYMT began offering rides on Fairmont "track cars" (small gas-powered vehicles once used by railway maintenance workers for transport to work sites) on the partially completed museum railroad. Around the same time, the neighboring
Rochester and Genesee Valley Railroad Museum began constructing their own demonstration railroad from their Industry depot north towards NYMT, and both operations were connected in 1993. Following the joining of the NYMT and RGVRRM tracks with a
golden spike ceremony, end-to-end track car operations began. ==Trolley era==