The Broadway production received mixed to negative reviews from critics. the theatre review aggregator
Did They Like It? includes 14 reviews of the show, of which one is categorized as positive, six are categorized as mixed, and seven are categorized as negative. Writing in
The New York Times,
Elisabeth Vincentelli called the show "sprawling, unwieldy, [and] surprisingly dull", and criticized the new songs written for the production, saying they "lack
Kander and Ebb's serrated edge". Greg Evans of
Deadline Hollywood praised the cast, particularly Ryan, but called the rest of the show "overstuffed" and criticized
David Thompson and Sharon Washington's book as "predictable [and] cliché-loaded". At
Time Out New York, Adam Feldman gave the production three stars out five, writing that a number featuring "a tap bonanza for workers balanced on the beams of an uncompleted skyscraper" was "as good a metaphor as any for the musical as a whole", concluding, "there's a lot to enjoy if you don't look down". Robert Hofler of
TheWrap was more positive, calling the first act "confused" but writing that the show "ultimately delivers its melting-pot message with intelligence, style and, yes, good old-fashioned razzle-dazzle". ==Awards and nominations==