Three sections of modern NY 417 were designated as part of Route 4, an unsigned
legislative route, by the
New York State Legislature in 1908. Route 4, a cross-state highway that began near
Lake Erie in
Chautauqua County and ended near the
Hudson River in
Orange County, proceeded east from
Salamanca to
Corning via
Olean,
Hinsdale,
Belvidere,
Wellsville,
Andover,
Hornell,
Jasper, and
Addison. Much of legislative Route 4 west of
Harriman—including all of the route between Salamanca and Corning—was designated as part of
NY 17 when the first set of posted routes in
New York were assigned in 1924. NY 17 was realigned in the
1930 renumbering of state highways in New York to follow more southerly alignments from Olean to Wellsville (via
Ceres) and from Andover to Jasper (via
Greenwood). As a result, NY 17 now followed the length of current NY 417 between Salamanca and Corning. and
reassurance markers on NY 417 eastbound in Bolivar. The reference marker's top row reads "17" for NY 17, NY 417's original designation. As sections of the
Southern Tier Expressway (STE) were completed, NY 17 was moved onto the expressway and NY 417 was assigned to sections of NY 17's former surface routing, beginning with the piece between
Steamburg and Salamanca on January 1, 1970. Ironically, that first section was the first to be deleted entirely when part of the route through the
Allegany Indian Reservation was closed to traffic in the early 1970s. Around the same time, NY 17 was relocated onto the mostly completed Southern Tier Expressway between
Allegany and Corning, allowing the NY 417 designation to be transferred to NY 17's former alignment between the two locations. A second section—from exit 20 on the STE to
US 219 in Salamanca—was added to NY 417 in the early 1980s following the completion of the STE between exits 20 and 21. The two segments were linked in the early 1990s following the completion of the expressway in the vicinity of Salamanca. Originally, NY 417 extended into Painted Post by way of a
concurrency with
US 15. NY 417 joined the freeway in
Erwin (exit 2) and followed it north to exit 44 of the STE, where both NY 417 and US 15 ended. The overlap was eliminated sometime after 1989. The new state highway, part of US 15 and NY 17 prior to the construction of the US 15 freeway, became an extension of NY 417. In 2008, NY 417 was extended again to a new terminus at
NY 415 in
Painted Post following the completion of the I-86 / US 15 interchange reconstruction project. This section of NY 417 also follows part of NY 17's pre-freeway alignment. Due to this situation, NY 951T exists in two segments: a western portion extending east from
NY 394 in
Coldspring and a eastern portion that originates at NY 417 in
Salamanca and continues west to Breed Run Road. Emergency work on the route between Breed Run and the former
NY 382 began in August 2014 in an effort to make the road passable after a portion of NY 951T washed out. Replacement of the bridge and much of the closed roadway began in December 2023. ==Major intersections==