Reviewing the arcade version,
Next Generation called the game "
NBA Jam on ice", and said it would be particularly appreciated since arcade hockey games were almost unheard of at the time. They applauded the game's full NHL licensing and player rosters, flaming pucks, two-on-two mode, commentary, and overall depth and playability of its hockey action, and concluded that "Williams rarely makes a bad move, and
Open Ice is testament to its conservative but consistent quality games." Brad Cook of
AllGame called the same game "a must play for any hockey fan." The PlayStation and PC versions divided reviewers. Jeff Kitts of
GameSpot, The Rookie of
GamePro, and Dean Hager of
Electronic Gaming Monthly all agreed that it offered fun and fast
NBA Jam-style hockey and was a faithful translation of the arcade version. In contrast, Hager's co-reviewer Kraig Kujawa said it "doesn't seem to capture the magic that made [NBA Jam] so popular", and that it compares poorly to its similar contemporary, ''
Wayne Gretzky's 3D Hockey for the Nintendo 64. Next Generation
agreed that it simply lacked the spark of NBA Jam'', and also "fails to capture the coin-op's flashy essence", citing smaller characters, missing frames of animation, a weaker color palette, and missing audio effects compared to the arcade version.
Official UK PlayStation Magazine said that players should "avoid the game at all costs." Stephen Poole of
GameSpot said of the PC version, "
NHL Open Ice isn't the kind of game you'll play for hours on end, but it is the kind that you can fire up just about any time for 20 or 30 minutes of fun, or leave running at your next party for your guests to enjoy. Except for the graphics in the full-screen mode, they'll think they're at the arcade - and with a game like this, you can't ask any more than that." ==See also==