The director originally had Adam Pally in mind for the role of Kevin and Hood's agent sent him the script. Pally was drawn to the film with the excitement of new challenges: "I really wanted the chance to play a romantic lead. In my brief career I’ve been playing a lot of best friends and goofballs and comedic sidekicks. I know I can do that, so I wanted to give this a shot. So, it was very fulfilling on that level." Pally then suggested Rosa Salazar for the part of Madeline. The director had this say about how the initial casting went: "I know this sounds funny, but it really was one of those things that magically came to fruition. My agent knew Adam Pally, who was on our wish list for the role of Kevin. She sent him the script, and within days he came on board. He then suggested Rosa [with whom he worked on the film Search Party] and a similar thing happened. It really worked out – I think Adam’s comedic flair brought the best out of Rosa’s more dramatic background." Krause and Hale were not confirmed until the filming had already started. According to the director: "At the start of production, we had still not cast the roles of Dr Newman [Hale] or Will [Krause]. Miraculously in the first [out of three] weeks, we saw a film poster with Tony Hale and we immediately thought, ‘Perfect!’ One of the film’s financiers, Haven Entertainment made a phone call and he was in. Peter Krause was more difficult but that was more because of an error on our part. Rosa knew him from [the TV series]
Parenthood and sent him an email. When he didn’t get back, we gave up on the idea and started looking for someone else. She realised she had his wrong email. Once that was sorted, we were pleasantly surprised how enthusiastic he was about the project and subsequently how easy-going he was to work with." ==Reception==