"No Church in the Wild" received mostly positive reviews from
music critics and was often described as a highlight from
Watch the Throne. Andy Gill of
The Independent stated "the best track is surely the opener 'No Church in the Wild', whose deep, detuned twang groove, over a marching organ motif, is the most striking music on the album, promising rather more than the rest of the record is able to deliver. Both this and the other stand-out track, "Made In America", feature assured vocal refrains from Frank Ocean, while the two rappers muse over familiar themes of loyalty, sexuality and maternal solidarity."
Rolling Stone claimed that it is one of the most musically impressive songs on
Watch the Throne and described the production as an "ominous, darkly funky bass groove and chilly synths tailor-made for Ocean's off-kilter crooning".
NOW claimed that the "uncomfortably visceral opener 'No Church In The Wild' – with its filthy Phil Manzanera guitar sample and mournful Frank Ocean chorus – cuts to the heart of Watch The Throne's power dynamic." However,
PopMatters criticized that the verses "feel a little out of focus compared to the hook and beat's opulence". Sputnikmusic's Tyler Fisher commented "88-Keys creates a positively epic opening track with 'No Church in the Wild', full of creeping guitar riffs and pulsating bass, building tension that simply never releases."
Rolling Stone named the track the sixth best song of the year, reporting that "with Hov and Yeezy getting deep into arcane theology, this track is just another high".
Dagbladet named it the 12th best song of 2011. In 2019,
XXL named the song as one of the 25 best Hip-Hop album intro's since 2000. ==Media usage==