Paul McCartney won the
Grammy Award for
Best Arrangement Accompanying Vocalists in 1971 for the song. The single was
certified Gold by the
Recording Industry Association of America for sales of over one million copies. According to
AllMusic critic Stewart Mason, fans of Paul McCartney's music are divided in their opinions of this song. Although some fans praise it as "one of his most playful and inventive songs", others criticize it for being "exactly the kind of cute self-indulgence that they find so annoying about his post-Beatles career". In a contemporary review of
Ram,
Jon Landau of
Rolling Stone gave "Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey" a negative review, saying the song is "a piece with so many changes it never seems to come down anywhere, and in the places that it does, sounds like the worst piece of light music Paul has ever done."
Cash Box said that the song "is bursting with fine melodies and interesting musical changes certain to please both AM and underground programmers".
Record World called it a "sound collage of Paul's best song ideas". A retrospective 2012
Pitchfork review by Jayson Greene states: "Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey is not only
Ram centerpiece, it is clearly one of McCartney’s five greatest solo songs. As the slash in the title hints, it's a multi-part song, starring two characters. To put its accomplishments in an egg-headed way: It fuses the conversational joy listeners associated with McCartney's melodic gift to the compositional ambition everyone assumed was Lennon's. To put it a simpler way: Every single second of this song is joyously, deliriously catchy, and no two seconds are the same." ==Later release==