On 21 February 2013, the Highways Department launched stage two of public consultation of
Our Future Railway, and proposed two schemes for the North Island line. In addition to a "Swap" scheme which was similar to previous proposals, the consultation documents also included a second "Interchange" scheme.
"Swap" scheme The existing
Tung Chung line would be extended along the northern coast of Hong Kong Island, with
Tamar,
Exhibition Centre,
Causeway Bay North and
Fortress Hill stations along the route. The extension would then connect eastwards to the existing
Island line at
Fortress Hill station, and continue on the remaining Island line section to
Chai Wan station. Concurrently, the
Tseung Kwan O line would extend from its current westbound terminus at
North Point station to the existing Island line at
Fortress Hill station, and continue on the remaining Island line to
Kennedy Town station. This scheme would greatly increase the number of stations reached directly by the Tung Chung line and the Tseung Kwan O line on Hong Kong Island, but east–west directional traffic along the existing Island line would be interrupted and require an interchange. In addition, the maximum train frequency between Fortress Hill and Chai Wan stations, which would be served by the Tung Chung line, would have to reduce by 8 trains per hour because the service frequency of the Tung Chung line is restricted by the capacity of the
Tsing Ma Bridge. The signalling system and rolling stock used on both lines are also different, so the “swap” scheme was not considered in the plan. ,
West Island line and
South Island line "Interchange" scheme Both the existing Tung Chung line and Tseung Kwan O line would be extended along the northern coast of Hong Kong Island. Three stations, namely Tamar, Exhibition Centre and Causeway Bay North, would be constructed along the extensions, and either Tamar or Causeway Bay North station would be chosen as an interchange between the two lines. This scheme would preserve the existing Island line in its current form and would not change the current commuting pattern between the Central, Western and Eastern Districts. However, as the Tung Chung and Tseung Kwan O lines would not be run on the Island line, passengers would still need to interchange as they currently do. Also, this arrangement would be less effective than the "Swap" scheme in relieving congestion, since although the number of stations and the area served has increased, the link with the current Island line would still be the same, unlike the "Swap" scheme. ==2014 plan==