Its
genus,
Margarops, is currently considered
monotypic; formerly the
scaly-breasted thrasher was placed in the same genus. However,
M. fusctaus is now known to be closer to the
Cinclocerthia tremblers. While this is not a
migratory bird, considerable
gene flow between populations appears to have taken place at least until fairly recently in its
evolutionary history. There are four
subspecies, two of which can be distinguished genetically:
M. f. fuscatus (the
nominate subspecies, which is found between the
Greater Antilles and
Antigua and Barbuda), and
M. f. densirostris (occurring from
Montserrat and
Guadeloupe southwards). When exactly the pearly-eyed thrasher lineage diverged from its relatives cannot be said with reasonable certainty, as no
fossils are known and the standard
molecular clock model cannot be applied to the
Mimidae, as
mutation rates seem to have varied over time. ==Distribution and habitat==