Viewership The series opened to 1.4 million viewers with four weeks of post-broadcast viewership included. The show was "the biggest comedy launch since
Derry Girls on Channel 4's streaming service".
Critical reception Everyone Else Burns has received critical acclaim, with a 90% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. Writing in
The Daily Telegraph Anita Singh said "there is much to enjoy here. It's not a comedy going for cheap laughs about Christianity. It is a show about family, and it has a lot of heart" and said that the comedy derives from a "subversion of norms". She also praised the writing, performances and characterisation “from the leads down to the supporting players", noting that "there are truths about family and friends that make it seem like more than a throwaway sitcom."
Lucy Mangan in
The Guardian commented that it is "simply very, very funny" and that the "hyper-religiosity is used to look anew at family dynamics and dysfunction; how blind you can be to abnormalities if they are all you know". Carol Midgely in
The Times described it as "a small delight" and praised the performance of Simon Bird and the cast, as well as the "sharply, wittily written" script, adding that "it is a brave comedy that targets religion, but only a clever one could do it with this much heart and jolliness."
The i described it as "funny as hell" while, in a four-star review for
The Evening Standard, Vicky Jessop wrote "who knew eternal damnation could be this fun?". Reception in the United States has been similarly positive.
Time Magazine described it as "a fantastically warped family sitcom” and “easily the best new broadcast comedy since Abbott Elementary".
The New York Times labelled it "a charmer - smart, distinctive, lovely".
The Hollywood Reporter called it "very funny" while
The LA Times named it "a dysfunctional family comedy you can believe in". Similarly positive reviews came from
The New York Post ("hell yeah") and
The Daily Beast, which called it "really goddamn funny" and "the sort of laughs-at-any-cost sitcom rarely made in the UK these days".
Accolades In February 2024, the series was nominated at the
Broadcast Awards in the Best Comedy Programme category. In March 2025, O'Flynn was nominated at the 2025
British Academy Television Awards in the Best Female Performance in a Comedy category.{{cite web|url= https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2025/mar/27/bafta-tv-awards-2025-nominations |website=The Guardian|accessdate=27 March 2025|title= Bafta TV awards 2025 nominations: full list ==References==