Impact In 2019, Bill Lamb from
About.com wrote that O'Connor's "emotional, gutsy performance made it a classic. Painful loss meets stunning vocal beauty with a perfectly understated instrumental arrangement." In their 2020 retrospective review, Matthew Hocter from
Albumism described it as a song "deeply rooted in emotion and despair which would go on to certify O'Connor and that song as one of music history's most unforgettable moments."
AllMusic editor Steve Huey called the song "stunning" and noted its "remarkable intimacy". In 2010, Tom Ewing of
Freaky Trigger noted it as a "very moving track", and added that it "captures the stasis, anger and devastation of a bad break-up with awful accuracy." He also complimented the music "whose stately, sympathetic pulse gives O’Connor the canvas she needs to be so devastating." In a 2000 review, Steven Wells from
NME said "it remains one of the best 'boo-hoo, my bloke's left me' pop songs ever recorded", and a "stark reminder that O'Connor is blessed with an amazing and unique voice". He concluded with that it "remains the outstanding highlight of her career to date. She's more than capable of surpassing it in the future. Less
Sade and more
Aretha, please." In 2009, Mark Richardson from
Pitchfork stated that "you have to look pretty hard to find a better expression in
pop music of the void that exists when a relationship ends." In a 2015 retrospective review,
Pop Rescue wrote that O'Connor "makes light work" of the track, and she's "having plenty of power to belt out the lyrics at the right points." The reviewer added that it is a "fantastic exhibit of
90s music". In 2004, Sal Cinquemani from
Slant Magazine felt that it perhaps is O'Connor's "greatest vocal achievement" and described it as a "classic torch song she quite simply owns."
Accolades • In 2003,
Q magazine ranked "Nothing Compares 2 U" at number 242 in their list of the "1001 Best Songs Ever". • In 2004, It was included at number 165 by
Rolling Stone in its list of the "500 Greatest Songs of All Time"; in 2021, it was moved to number 184. • In 2007,
VH1 ranked it number 10 on "100 Greatest Songs of the 90s". • In 2008, the song was listed at number 77 on
Billboards "Greatest Songs of All Time". • In 2010,
Pitchfork included the song at number 37 on their
Top 200 Tracks of the 90s. • In 2011,
Time magazine included "Nothing Compares 2 U" in its (unranked) list of "All-TIME 100 Songs". • In 2012,
Porcys listed the song at number 60 in their ranking of "100 Singles 1990-1999", noting that "it's probably one of the noblest, most dignified slow songs of the decade". • In 2019,
Stacker placed the song at number 20 in their list of "Best 90s pop songs". • In 2020,
The Guardian ranked the song at number 12 in its list of the "100 Greatest UK No 1s" • In 2020,
Cleveland.com ranked "Nothing Compares 2 U" the best
Billboard Hot 100 number-one song of the 1990s in 2020, calling it "one of the greatest love songs ever written". == Prince versions ==