In a review of
So Far Gone,
Billboard's Scott Glaysher ranked "November 18th" as the third-best song off the mixtape, behind
Best I Ever Had. He calls the song a "perfect example of Drake being able to seamlessly rap and sing on the turn of a dime; one moment he’s hitting a dark croon and another he rhymes with perfect wordplay". Rose Lilah of
HotNewHipHop ranked "November 18th" as the ninth-best Drake song and found the production to be "sleek and cold, appropriately matching the weather on the date in question, and Drake mirrors this style in his approach to the vocals".
Complex praised the song, calling it "one of the greatest lean sing-a-long songs of the last 10 years". == Live performances ==