The anomalous values for the magnetic moments of the nucleons presented a theoretical quandary for the 30 years from the time of their discovery in the early 1930s to the development of the quark model in the 1960s. By this theory, a neutron is partly, regularly and briefly, disassociated into a proton, an electron, and a neutrino as a natural consequence of
beta decay. By this idea, the magnetic moment of the neutron was caused by the fleeting existence of the large magnetic moment of the electron in the course of these quantum-mechanical fluctuations, the value of the magnetic moment determined by the length of time the virtual electron was in existence. The theory proved to be untenable, however, when
H. Bethe and R. Bacher showed that it predicted values for the magnetic moment that were either much too small or much too large, depending on speculative assumptions. Similar considerations for the electron proved to be much more successful. In
quantum electrodynamics (QED), the
anomalous magnetic moment of a particle stems from the small contributions of quantum mechanical fluctuations to the
magnetic moment of that particle. The g-factor for a "Dirac"
magnetic moment is predicted to be for a negatively charged, spin-1/2 particle. For particles such as the
electron, this "classical" result differs from the observed value by around 0.1%; the difference compared to the classical value is the anomalous magnetic moment. The
g-factor for the electron is measured to be QED is the theory of the mediation of the electromagnetic force by photons. The physical picture is that the
effective magnetic moment of the electron results from the contributions of the "bare" electron, which is the Dirac particle, and the cloud of "virtual", short-lived electron–positron pairs and photons that surround this particle as a consequence of QED. The effects of these quantum mechanical fluctuations can be computed theoretically using
Feynman diagrams with loops. The one-loop contribution to the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron, corresponding to the first-order and largest correction in QED, is found by calculating the
vertex function shown in the diagram on the right. The calculation was discovered by
J. Schwinger in 1948. Computed to fourth order, the QED prediction for the electron's anomalous magnetic moment agrees with the experimentally measured value to more than 10 significant figures, making the magnetic moment of the electron one of the most accurately verified predictions in the history of
physics. The
Yukawa interaction for nucleons was discovered in the mid-1930s, and this nuclear force is mediated by
pion mesons. The Feynman diagram at right is roughly the first-order diagram, with the role of the virtual particles played by pions. As noted by
A. Pais, "between late 1948 and the middle of 1949 at least six papers appeared reporting on second-order calculations of nucleon moments". These theoretical approaches were incorrect because the nucleons are composite particles with their magnetic moments arising from their elementary components, quarks. ==Quark model of nucleon magnetic moments==