Although Leonardo's first description of the octant projection has been proved by Tyler, or
Eugène Müntz (1899 – citing Harrisse authority from 1892, although none of them talks about the projection's sketch in
Codex Atlanticus). Other scholars accept explicitly both (map and
projection: "the eight of a supposed globe represented in a plane"), completely as a Leonardo's work, describing the projection as the first of this type, among them,
R. H. Major (1865) in his work
Memoir on a mappemonde by Leonardo da Vinci, being the earliest map hitherto known containing the name of America, Grothe, the
Enciclopedia universal ilustrada europeo-americana (1934), or David Bower in his work (2012) "The unusual projection for one of John Dee's maps of 1580". Others also accept explicitly both (map and
projection) as authentic, although leaving in the air Leonardo's direct hand, giving the authorship of the work to one of his disciples as
Nordenskjold states in his book
Facsimile-Atlas (1889) confirmed by Dutton (1995) and many others: "on account of the remarkable projection..not by Leonardo himself, but by some ignorant clerk", or Keunig (1955) being more precise: "by one of his followers at his direction". == Octant projection layouts ==