Customers' opinions vary on how similar the Impossible Whopper is to the regular Whopper; some say that it is almost identical, others think it is not even close. Megan Schaltegger of
Delish found that the burger tasted "nearly identical to an OG Whopper", saying that she double-checked her receipt to make sure it really was not meat.
Meat industry lobbyist Eric Bohl likewise said "If I didn't know what I was eating, I would have no idea it was not beef." Writing for
The Washington Post, Tim Carman said that the Impossible Whopper patty is more flavorful than the traditional beef patty because the bar is set extremely low. He concluded: "The product is close enough to beef that your brain is willing to fill in the rest of the flavors, even if somewhere in the dark recesses of your cerebral cortex, you know it's all a lie." Similarly, the
Tampa Bay Times Christopher Spata said that eating the two versions together made the Impossible Whopper feel inadequate. Nonetheless, Rothbarth expressed approval for Burger King's decision to introduce the Impossible Whopper.
The Spoon Chris Albrecht said it was good but "definitely wouldn't fool a meat eater", concluding that he would order one again in the future for environmental reasons. and Zachary Fagenson of the
Miami New Times said it was "a near-perfect circle with right angles at its edges". One called it a "solid meatless option", while the other concluded that like the regular Whopper, it has the characteristic low quality of
fast food. == Vegetarian and vegan options and cross-contamination ==