The first church building was built and designed by architect John McComb, Sr. on the corner of Beekman and
Nassau Streets. It opened doors on New Year's Day in 1768. When the congregation moved uptown, the
New-York Daily Times used the site for its new headquarters, a dedicated five-story building. In 1858, the congregation moved to a new building on
Murray Hill at 37th Street and
Fifth Avenue since its congregation had moved farther uptown. The dedication was on October 31. On April 23, 1910,
Mark Twain's funeral was held at the church and the Rev.
Henry van Dyke Jr. officiated. By the late 1930s, the congregation had decided to move yet farther north. The building at Fifth and 37th was sold and demolished in 1938. The church merged with Park Avenue Presbyterian Church in 1937, and the joint congregation built the 91st Street location. The church also acquired a residence on East 92nd Street to use as a Parish House. The cornerstone to the current building was laid on November 25, 1938, in the presence of Mayor
Fiorello La Guardia. ==Brick Church School==