The Philadelphia Inquirer wrote that
One Man Mutiny "contains riff-driven rockers, a couple of tunes with a countryish bent, and quieter moments that recall Replacements leader Paul Westerberg at his most reflective and openhearted."
The Boston Globe noted the "loose-limbed, Stones-y rave-ups." The
Arkansas Democrat-Gazette deemed the album a "gritty set that has some nice slide guitar action."
Cincinnati CityBeat called the album "raw and elemental Stonesy rock with twangy overtones, circa
Exile on Main Street." The
Long Island Press considered "Match Made in Hell" to be "a tongue-in-cheek odd couple ditty with a luau vibe." ==Track listing==