The film has an 88% 'Fresh' rating on
Rotten Tomatoes, citing 'generally favorable and positive reviews.
Roger Ebert gave the film three stars out of four and wrote that it was "funny and touching and makes you feel good."
Vincent Canby of
The New York Times stated that despite how predictable the film was, "predictability has the effect of enriching our interest as we wait to see not what will happen but
how it's brought about. A lot of the success of the 'how' in 'One on One' has to do with the performance by writer-actor Benson, whose clean-cut naïveté masks a surprising moral strength, which, even if it's not very common, is something we'd all like to believe in."
Charles Champlin of the
Los Angeles Times declared that "the customers who liked 'Rocky' will find a whole lot to like in the film ... It is brisk, pointed, very funny and greatly engaging." Joseph McBride of
Variety called it "a trite and disappointing little film" that "follows the 'Rocky' formula about the underdog-turned-hero but fails to ignite the emotions." Gary Arnold of
The Washington Post called the film "a wobbly attempt at junior division 'Rocky,'" with "fitfully appealing interludes" but "Whenever the mood shifts toward True Romance or pathos, the movie begins to disintegrate." Clyde Jeavons of
The Monthly Film Bulletin wrote that the screenwriters "take the easy way out, opting for the old Hollywood winning-through-against-all-odds formula which makes their sporting hero's final rejection of his mentor-cum-tormentor both irrelevant and gratuitous and not in the least the 'surprise' ending that was intended."
TV Guide says- 'ONE ON ONE is an earnest, mostly believable study of the psychological struggle that can occur between player and coach. Handling the ball as well as he does his lines, Benson is convincing both as a basketball player and as a young man undergoing emotional turmoil'. ==Soundtrack==