In 2021, the Office of the
Auditor General of Ontario (OAGO) completed its first value-for-money audit of OMVIC. The Auditor General reported the following concerns, among others: "Our audit found that about 50% of the 5,400 complaints against motor vehicle dealers handled by OMVIC between 2016 and 2020 resulted in no resolution for consumers. In these cases, consumers were left with no choice but to pursue their dispute in civil court. We also found that OMVIC does not have the authority to compel a motor vehicle dealer to compensate a consumer, even in instances where OMVIC determines that the dealer has breached the law." p. 1 "Our audit also found that OMVIC has been accumulating large surpluses instead of using the revenues it generates to enhance and improve consumer protection." ...."We also found that while OMVIC committed to increasing consumer awareness, increasing its spending in this area from $1.2 million in 2015 to nearly $2 million in 2019, 73% of Ontarians it surveyed between 2016 and 2020 were not aware of OMVIC and the protections it offered to vehicle purchasers." pp. 1–2 "We also noted that OMVIC’s Board of Directors is heavily represented by motor vehicle dealers even though OMVIC is a consumer protection agency. As well, we found that OMVIC does not have term limits for its Board members. As a result, we found that at the time of our audit, some Board members had served on the Board for 14 years or more. Over their tenure on the Board, these members held key positions such as Chair, Vice-Chair and Secretary-Treasurer. Our concerns about Board governance at OMVIC also included interference with the independent function of the Compensation Fund Board, and approving claims for alcohol and meals at rates in excess of OMVIC’s allowable limits." p2 OMVIC has acknowledged the areas identified for improvement in the Auditor General's report and remains committed to enhancing its performance. According to the latest report from OAGO in 2023, it was mentioned that as of October 20, 2023, OMVIC had fully implemented more than half of the actions that were recommended in their 2021 annual report. The latest report (2023) also claimed that OMVIC has kept their reports accurate, complete and consistent on their website. They have also reported the customer surveys it conducts, and reported on completed inspections and site visits separately. Whilst it was openly recommended that OMVIC’s meal reimbursement rates were higher than those of the Ontario government, the latest audit report informs us that the new policy now prohibits reimbursement of alcohol use, unless the CEO has signed off on it. According to an article in the
Vancouver Sun in 2021, “Ontario consumers may not know it, but we have a gem of an organization in this province that makes purchasing vehicles much safer.” The organization recognizes the importance of consumer protection in the motor vehicle industry and continues to work diligently toward addressing the shortcomings highlighted in the audit. By implementing the recommendations provided in the report and adopting measures to strengthen oversight, OMVIC aims to better fulfill its mandate of safeguarding consumers and ensuring fair practices within the industry. ==See also==