Flight vs. echolocation Onychonycteris finneyi was the strongest evidence so far in the debate on whether bats developed
echolocation before or after they evolved the ability to fly.
O. finneyi was, based on biomechanical analysis of its
fossils, capable of both gliding and powered flight in both the hyperdense atmosphere of the Early Eocene as modelled based on geochemical proxies and an atmosphere characteristic of the present-day.
O. finneyi had well-developed wings, and could clearly fly, but lacked the enlarged
cochlea of all
extant echolocating bats, closely resembling the
old world fruit bats which do not echolocate. However, an independent evaluation of the
Onychonycteris reference fossil in 2010 provided some evidence for other bone structures indicative of
laryngeal echolocation, raising the possibility that
Onychonycteris finneyi possessed the ability to echolocate after all. and
Icaronycteris gunnelli. ==References==