The relationship between opalines and other
protists has been a subject of great controversy since the late 19th century, and is not completely resolved at present. Initially, microscopists believed that the thousands of rhythmically beating hair-like structures which cover their surface were
cilia, and they placed the opalines in
Ciliophora. In the early 20th century other aspects of opaline biology clearly differentiated them from the ciliates and they were placed in
Sarcomastigophora, with the
amoebae and
flagellates. In the 1980s, detailed
ultrastructural studies of
Opalina ranarum revealed that they share many features with the
heterokonts of the family Proteromonadidae. A new order—Slopalinida Patterson 1985—was proposed to include the members of the families Proteromonadidae Grassé 1952 and Opalinidae Claus 1874. In 2004, the first reliable opaline genetic sequence data supported the
monophyletic nature of the order Slopalinida. The authors of that study considered the opalines to be a family (Opalinidae) within the order Slopalinida. There are currently about 200 recognized species of opalines in 5 genera:
Opalina Purkinje and Valentin 1835,
Protoopalina Metcalf 1918,
Cepedea Metcalf 1920,
Zelleriella Metcalf 1920, and
Protozelleriella Delvinquier et al. 1991. Two additional genera,
Hegneriella Earl 1971 and
Bezzenbergeria Earl 1973, have not been considered as valid by subsequent authors (p. 249) The 5 recognized genera differ in terms of the number of nuclei, the appearance and location of the falx (two short, sickle-shaped rows of flagella), and whether the long rows of flagella (called "kineties") cover the body evenly or if there is a "bald spot". Due to the differences in body shape among the different life cycle stages within a species, the use of overall body shape - whether flat or cylindrical - to differentiate the genera has been de-emphasized. ==Life cycle==