The fact that the prize excludes male writers has provoked comment. After the prize was founded,
Auberon Waugh nicknamed it the "
Lemon Prize", while
Germaine Greer said there would soon be a prize for "writers with red hair."
A. S. Byatt, who won the 1990
Man Booker Prize, said it was a "sexist prize", claiming that "such a prize was never needed." She refused to have her work considered for this prize. In 2007, former editor of
The Times Simon Jenkins called the prize "sexist." In 2008, writer
Tim Lott said that "the Orange Prize is sexist and discriminatory, and it should be shunned." On the other hand, in 2011 London journalist Jean Hannah Edelstein wrote about her own "wrong reasons" for supporting the prize: Unfortunately, the evidence shows that the experiences of male and female writers after they set their pens down are often distinctively different. That's why I've changed my mind about the Orange prize. I still agree with Byatt that the idea of female-specific subject matter is spurious, but I don't think that's what the prize rewards.In 2012
Cynthia Ozick, writing in
The New York Times, said the Prize "was not born into an innocent republic of letters" when it comes to a history of women writers being discriminated against. She concluded: "For readers and writers, in sum, the more prizes the better, however they are structured, and philosophy be damned." In 1999
Lola Young, chair of the judges' panel, claimed that British female literature fell into two categories, either "insular and parochial" or "domestic in a piddling kind of way."
Linda Grant suffered accusations of
plagiarism following her award in 2000. In 2001 a panel of male critics strongly criticised the Orange shortlist and produced its own. In 2007, broadcaster
Muriel Gray, chair of the panel, said that judges had to wade through "a lot of dross" to get to the shortlist, but praised that year's winner,
Half of a Yellow Sun by Nigerian author
Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, saying: "This is a moving and important book by an incredibly exciting author." In 2019,
Akwaeke Emezi's debut novel,
Freshwater, was nominated – the first time a
non-binary transgender author has been nominated for the prize. Women's prize judge Professor Kate Williams said that the panel did not know Emezi was non-binary when the book was chosen, but she said Emezi was happy to be nominated. Non-binary commentator Vic Parsons wrote that the nomination raised uncomfortable questions, asking: "would a non-binary author who was
assigned male at birth have been longlisted? I highly doubt it." After the nomination, it was announced that the Women's Prize Trust was working on new guidelines for
transgender, non-binary, and
genderfluid authors. The Women's Prize later asked for Emezi's "sex as defined by law" when submitting
The Death of Vivek Oji for inclusion. Emezi chose to withdraw, and said that they would not submit their future novels for consideration, calling the requirement
transphobic. Joanna Prior, Chair of Trustees for the Women's Prize for Fiction, has stated that in the prize's terms and conditions, "the word 'woman' equates to a cis woman, a transgender woman, or anyone who is legally defined as a woman or of the female sex." ==See also==